Ask An Agent


Get free insurance advice on demand



How do I decide if the insurance policy covering my 2007 Acura MDX should be liability only?

Our insurance company quoted us $986/year annually with a $1000 deductible or $1062/year with a $500 deductible. According to Kelley Blue Book, the value of the vehicle is $6200. Does it then make sense to have liability only since the annual premium is >10% of the vehicle value? We would like to keep the vehicle for several more years as it’s otherwise in great condition.

Agent Answer

Neil Richardson

There are a few things to consider when deciding between a “full coverage” or liability only policy:

  1. Determine an estimated fair market value of your vehicle. While Kelley Blue Book may offer useful estimates, I recommend using NADA guide since most insurance companies use them to determine a vehicle’s value at the time of a claim.
  2. Decide on a deductible. With older vehicles, choosing a lower deductible will help to maximize the value you would get for the car if it were totaled.
  3. Look at the difference in premium between a “full coverage” policy that includes the deductible you want and a liability only policy. If the amount of money you save in premium by going with liability only is not enough to cover or replace the vehicle if something happens then it’s probably best to maintain comprehensive and collision coverage.
Consider that, if your vehicle were to be totaled in the next year and you pay $1062 in premium and a $500 deductible to file a claim, you would be paying only $1,562 to cover your totaled vehicle. Assuming that your vehicle’s value is $6,200, you would ultimately be getting $4,638 for your car. A liability only policy would likely cost much less than the “full coverage” policy, but you would be faced with repairing or replacing the vehicle out of your own pocket if it is damaged. Keep this in mind as the vehicle’s value continues to decrease. Once the premium amount and deductible get closer to the value of your vehicle then you should consider switching to liability coverage; sooner if you can afford to repair or replace it on your own.

Was this helpful?

1 0
  • Didn't Find What You Were Looking For?

    Ask us another question and an insurance expert will get back to you with an answer.

Looking to save money on your car insurance?

Learn More