Comprehensive vs. Collision Insurance Coverage

Protect your vehicle from expected and the unexpected.

Comprehensive vs. collision coverage


Even if you’re not very familiar with car insurance, you’ve probably heard of collision or comprehensive coverage. But you might not know what it means. Before we go into deeper detail, all you have to know is that comprehensive and collision insurance coverage offer physical protection to your vehicle. The finer details of this, including how much it can cost and if you’re required to have it, are coming up next.

Please note; if you’re looking for an in-depth review of what these coverages are rather than the difference between them, see our guide to comprehensive insurance or our guide to collision coverage.


Comprehensive vs. collision coverage
  1. What’s the difference between these coverages?
  2. Comprehensive vs. collision claim
  3. How much do they cost?
  4. Additional resources




What’s the difference between these coverages?


As we stated, comprehensive and collision only offer physical coverage to your vehicle. Where this physical coverage differs concerns what caused the damage to your vehicle. Collision coverage refers to damage caused by an actual collision — you collide with another car, a wall, or a pole. Comprehensive, on the other hand, refers to things that generally happen outside of your control. Things like theft, vandalism, and animal-related damage. Here’s a handy breakdown:


Comprehensive vs Collision Insurance Coverage

Collision Comprehensive
Colliding with a fixed object Colliding with an animal
At-Fault accidents Theft
Crashing your vehicle due to ice/weather related events Weather-related damage (flood or hail damage)
Hit and Runs Vandalism

These coverages are usually paired with your liability insurance coverage, which provides protection against damage you do to other people (bodily injury) or their property (property damage).



Do I have to have both comprehensive and collision coverage?

Because of the nature of driving, there are more collision claims than comprehensive. Thus, you might want an insurance coverage policy that only includes collision protection. However, it’s very unlikely that you will be able to receive that. You might, however, be able to have different deductibles for your collision versus comprehensive insurance coverage. Your deductible is what you pay in the event you file a collision or comprehensive claim. The remainder is covered by your insurance company. This would vary by company, however.



Do you have to have either comprehensive or collision coverage?

The only insurance coverage that you’re required to have by law is your liability insurance (sometimes uninsured motorist or personal injury protection as well if your state requires). However, if you’re leasing or financing a vehicle, you’re more than likely required to insure the vehicle with comprehensive and collision coverage.

Even if you own the vehicle outright, you still might want this coverage. If you’re planning on selling your vehicle in the future or using it as collateral for loan, you’re going to want to make sure the vehicle is protected to ensure it’s value.

While we stated the major difference between comprehensive and collision, there’s another aspect to consider: how using them affects your car insurance coverage premium.





Comprehensive vs Collision Claim


This is one of the bigger differences between comprehensive and collision coverage. Because of what it is used to cover against, a collision claim is often seen as an "at-fault accident". Meaning, it will raise your rate. A comprehensive claim, on the other hand, is often seen as outside the control of the driver and thus usually doesn’t affect your premium as much.


Comprehensive vs Collision Claims: Annual Rate Increase

Collision Claim Comprehensive Claim
$687 $98

As you can see, the difference between a collision claim and a comprehensive claim is about $589 a year.





How much do they cost?


On average, your comprehensive and collision coverage takes up about half of your insurance coverage premium. You can save some premium by raising your deductibles, as your deductibles are inversely related to your premium.


Average Annual Cost of Insurance Coverage

Coverage Level Average Annual Premium
Liability Only $672
$500 Deductible $1,427
$1,000 Deductible $1,268

Compare over 200 insurance companies at once!




Additional resources


Comprehensive and collision coverage are your two best and most common options for protection to your vehicle. If you’re looking for more information regarding comprehensive and collision coverage or insurance in general, see our additional articles.


Liability insurance: what is it and do you need it?

Comprehensive insurance coverage

Collision insurance coverage

All you need to know about a $500 deductible

All you need to know about a $1,000 deductible

Uninsured motorist coverage: what you need to know


Recent Questions:

Comprehensive vs. Collision Insurance Coverage

My son stole my car how does the insurance work

Jun 18, 2018

Can I file a claim if my son stole my car? I was in my house and my son took ...

How can I file a glass claim without comprehensive coverage?

Jun 13, 2018

My windshield was damaged by a baseball. Should I file a claim for the damage? I don’t have collision or ...

Can I add full coverage later if I only have liability

Jun 09, 2018

If I just have liability, can i, at a later date, change to full coverage? Or do I have to ...

Can I add full coverage later if I only have liability

Jun 09, 2018

If I just have liability, can i, at a later date, change to full coverage? Or do I have to ...

Additional Resources:

Comprehensive vs. Collision Insurance Coverage

8 Things You Didn’t Know Your Car Insurance Covers
8 Things You Didn’t Know Your Car Insurance Covers
Feb 23, 2017

As a licensed insurance agent, I’ve been asked time and again what car insurance covers and why it’s necessary. It...

Car Insurance Myths: What is Full Coverage, Really?
Car Insurance Myths: What is Full Coverage, Really?
Sep 30, 2014

It’s not hard to understand why there are so many common car insurance myths: Between the semi-legalese language of policies...

“Acts of God” and What They Mean for Your Auto Insurance
“Acts of God” and What They Mean for Your Auto Insurance
Jan 18, 2016

A tree falls on your parked car, torrential rains flood your vehicle, golf-ball sized hail dents the entire body of...

Why You Need to Prepare for Floods (Whether You Live in a Flood Zone or Not)
Why You Need to Prepare for Floods (Whether You Live in a Flood Zone or Not)
Aug 07, 2017

Dozens of major flooding events surface across the U.S. each year – and often in regions (even cities!) that aren’t...