Car Insurance for 16-Year-Olds

Sweet 16: good for parties, bad for your car insurance

So, why is insurance so expensive for 16-year-olds?

Nearly every factor within auto insurance premiums comes down to one simple question: what’s the risk? Statistically speaking, a 16-year-old driver is less experienced and thus more likely to receive a citation or cause an accident. In the eyes of an insurance company, that means more risk and a greater need for financial protection — i.e., higher premiums. In this regard, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that the average 16-year-old in 2016 paid an annual premium of $6,491 for insurance compared to the national average of $1,323.

There are many things an insurance company looks at when determining your rate and the rate of your new driver. Age, gender, where you live, and what you drive affect how much you pay. And when you’re paying significantly more for your newly-licensed driver, you want to make sure you’re getting the best deal possible. So, let's break it down. Starting first with which company should you choose.

How to find cheap car insurance for 16-year-olds

  1. By company
  2. By Age
  3. By Gender
  4. By Location
  5. By Vehicle
  6. What are some ways to save?
  7. Car Insurance for 16-year-olds: Summed Up

What about by company?

In a survey we completed to find which car insurance company was the cheapest for teens, we discovered that Geico provided the lowest rate with all other metrics constant with Progressive as number 2. Now, our survey used the profile of a 17-year-old driver on their parent's policy within 5 zip codes across the US. Considering that we are talking about 16-year-olds, and you and your driver might not fit the profile we used, you should look at many different companies in order to find the best rate for you. Because your teen's rate changes so much as they age, we recommend shopping for car insurance every 6 months. Do that here with us.

Although the selected profile might be different from your family's, you can still our data as a foundational jumping-off point. 

Our Findings: Car Insurance for 17-year-olds

Location State Farm Allstate Geico Progressive Liberty Mutual
Columbus, OH $1,964 $1,355 $544 $858 $1,002
McKinney, TX $4,065 $4,019 $1,082 $1,075 N/A
Fresno, CA $2,533 $1,088 $1,238 $1,272 $2,919
Scranton, PA $3,015 $1,524 $708 $1,280 $846
Aurora, CO $3,419 $3,490 $1,363 $1,673 $1,935
Average $2,999 $2,295 $987 $1,231 $1,676

Why do your child's age matter?

Average Premium on Family Plan
As we stated, your age is a huge rating factor for your young driver's premium. Out of every age group, drivers between 16-19 pay more than any other driver. It really just comes down to the lack of driving experience combined with the probability a young driver will take more risks, which could lead to a claim pay out by your insurance company. This is the average rate per a 6-month policy for a 16-year-old added to a family plan in which the parents are both 50-year-olds, driving a 2012 Honda Accord and a 2012 Ford Escape perspectively.

Age Premium
16 $2,617
17 $2,485
18 $2,315

How does your gender affect your premium?

Just like the age of your child, gender can affect their insurance premium. Statistically, a young male driver is more likely to receive a citation or be in an accident than a young female driver. As such, they are more expensive to insure. On average, 16-year-old males pay $295 more per 6-month policy period for insurance than their female counterparts. Still, it's worth considering that as you age, the difference between men and women becomes less significant. In fact, some states don't use gender as a metric for determining car insurance rates.

Average Premiums for Teens

Age Male Female Difference
16 $2,794 $2,440 $354
17 $2,645 $2,325 $320
18 $2,449 $2,180 $269
19 $2,154 $1,919 $235
Average $2,511 $2,216 $295

Why does your location matter?

Where you live also plays a big role for you and your young driver’s insurance premium. As insurance as a whole is state regulated, variations in laws guarantee there will be discrepancies in premiums. As a rule of thumb, most states require a mandatory minimum coverage for other people and their property, but the monetary amount of this coverage vary. Moreover, the number of people in your state can also impact your child’s insurance rate. States with a low population density, such as Midwestern states like Ohio, tend to have lower premiums than states with more people. Keeping with the idea of risk management, the more drivers your state has, the more likely you are to be near other drivers (with the potential of a collision) and insurance companies have to cover that additional risk.

Annual Premium for Most Expensive States for 16-Year-Olds

State Premium
Louisiana $12,433
Michigan $9,411
Texas $8,887
Delaware $7,311
New York $6,915

Does my child’s car affect my premium?

The type of car your teen drives definitely affects your insurance rate . . . as it does with anyone. For example, a teenager with an off-road capable truck is statistically more likely to have a higher insurance rate than one without. As a good general rule, any vehicle with a high MSRP will have a high premium because on the expense your insurance company will have to replace it. So, if you’re looking for a cheaper rate for your teen driver, you should stick to a simple sedan.

How can I save?

Now that we’ve talked about why it is so expensive to insure 16-year-olds, let’s talk about ways to save.

Good Student Discount

If your driver has the grades, you might want to consider the good student discount. Your insurance company would require proof, such as a transcript. The requirements and amount of discount may vary, so you would need to consult with your personal company for details.

Savings for Good Student and Good Driver Discount

Age Male Female
16 $439 $248
17 $348 $222
18 $338 $197

Defensive Driver Discount

Another option is what’s called a defensive driver discount. Young drivers who have taken a professional driving course are less likely to receive a citation or get into an accident. Like the good student discount, your insurance company will usually require proof of this such as a receipt. Not every insurance company offers this discount, so ask your insurance company beforehand!

Keep a Clean Driving Record

Because teens are already more likely to be in an accident or get a citation, it is imperative for low rates to keep them out of any legal trouble. Texting while driving, speeding, or being in an at-fault accident can seriously affect your premium. In a state-by-state breakdown, DUIs, and racing (on average the most expensive citations) raise insurance premiums at least 40%. Moreover, most insurance companies offer a good driver discount which is dependent on a clean driving record.

Average Increase in Annual Premium in 2016

Accident/Violation Premium Increase
Speeding 11 - 15 MPH Over Limit $141
Speeding 16 - 20 MPH Over Limit $153
Speeding 21 - 25 MPH Over Limit $165
At-Fault Accident $306
Reckless Driving $499
Racing $523
DUI $529

Consider, however, that these numbers are a holistic average of the entire US population. If your teen receives a citation or violation, you can expect the rates to be significantly higher.

Keep Them on Your Policy

Although it's tempting to get your child their own policy, bear in mind our data shows that it is actually more expensive — about $452 more per 6-month policy period. Moreover, most insurance companies require anyone that lives in your residence, as a 16-year-old would be, that is above legal driving age be either added to your policy or excluded altogether. Meaning, if your teen were to use your vehicle for any reason, they risk not having coverage because they have their own policy and are thus excluded from yours.

Shop Around

There are many things that go into your insurance quote, as we discussed. So, any time there is a change in your location, your age, your car, etc., you should check with other insurance companies to make sure you're getting the best possible rate. For example, because your teen's rates vary so much as they age, any time they have a birthday you should look at as many companies as possible in order to make sure you're getting the best possible rate. Only with us can you examine hundreds of companies at once.

Summary: Car Insurance for 16-year-olds

At the end of the day, you should expect to the premium for a 16-year-old driver to be higher than any other age group. Insurance companies see their proclivity for accidents and lack of driving experience as major red flags and thus, charge quite high for them. But, considering companies like Geico and Progressive as well as owning a moderate car, being good student, and attending defensive driving classes are some good places to start in order to save on car insurance. However, the absolute best way to save on car insurance is to look for rates every 6 months. Only with the The Zebra can you shop over 200 car insurance companies at once.

Ready to start comparing rates?

Compare Now