Cheap Car Insurance for Canceled Policies

Don't go too long without being covered — it could hurt you in the future.

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.

What happens if my car insurance is canceled?

If you’re seen as a high-risk insurance client, most companies will insure you and your vehicle — but it will cost you. If an elevated premium won't cover the risk, your insurance company could cancel your policy outright. The tricky part is what comes next: many companies have the same redlines, i.e., guidelines, that dictate to whom they will sell policies. If Geico cancels your coverage because you’ve had too many claims, you might not get able to get coverage from Progressive for the same reason. That’s where we come in. Let’s explore getting car insurance after a canceled policy.

Here are our talking points:

  1. Is it legal for my insurance company to cancel my policy?
  2. What are common reasons for getting car insurance canceled?
  3. What are my next steps?
  4. How do I get insurance after a canceled policy?

Is it illegal for my car insurance company to drop me?

Although auto insurance is required in nearly every state, an insurance company has the legal right to cancel your policy if you violate the terms and conditions stated in the original contract. If you break your policy, your insurance company will be acting within its legal rights and self-interest to deny coverage at policy renewal or cancel your policy immediately. After this, the burden of getting new insurance will fall on you.

Why do car insurance companies cancel policies?

As we stated, your insurance company can drop you if you violate the terms of conditions of your policy. Here are some common violations:

  • License suspension
  • Frequent claims
  • High claims payout, especially bodily injury or medical payments
  • Owning high-performing or altered vehicles
  • Failure to provide necessary documentation
  • Any combination of all of the above

Some minor infractions may not trigger a policy cancellation. If you forget to sign a document, your insurance company will most likely reactivate your policy after you sign the document. If, however, you fail to turn in documentation of previous insurance history because you don’t have any insurance history, you could be denied coverage from that company. Many companies, such as Farmers, require you have 6 months of continuous coverage in order to purchase a policy.

What happens next?

You have a lot of options after your coverage is dropped. First, ensure you have a clear answer as to why your policy was dropped. This way, if it is something small such as missing a payment or failing to turn a document it, you can make amends and restart your coverage.

If your policy was canceled and you’re unable to reactivate it, you should consider non-standard car insurance companies. Many major insurance companies carry the same thresholds for uninsurability. Meaning, if Progressive non-renewed you because of too many claims, Allstate might not issue you a policy for the same reason. However, non-standard companies might be more willing to insure you.

A non-standard company is, to put it simply, an insurance company specifically designed for drivers with high-risk rating factors. Bear in mind that non-standard companies might not offer the same level of coverage you once received through a major insurer. This could mean coverage no longer extending to rental cars, to “permissive users” — people who use your vehicle irregularly but would be covered in the event of an accident — or covering other circumstances. It’s important to read the fine print to understand what you are and are not covered for.

Now what? How to buy insurance after having your policy canceled

Just because one insurance company didn’t want you, doesn't mean they all won't. Shopping around and assessing as many companies as possible will help you find the best insurance rate after your cancelation. Only with The Zebra can you compare hundreds of different companies at once — standard and non-standard alike. We’ll get you covered again.

Compare over 200 insurance companies at once!

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.

Recent Questions:

Cheap Car Insurance for Canceled Policies

Car insurance rate went up after leaving the country

Aug 17, 2018
Location pin iconTulsa, OK

I went out of the country for a few months and stuck my car in storage and canceled coverage. Why ...

Finding car insurance with a long violation and ticket history

Jul 15, 2018
Location pin iconBrooklyn, NY

As of July 7th, my current car insurance company is canceling my policy with them. My wife and I (and ...

My home insurance company won’t give us a refund

Mar 29, 2018
Location pin iconDearborn Heights, Minnesota

We have been paying over 3,000 a year for insurance on a vacant property. We inquired as to how we ...

How do I recover my refund if I canceled a policy the day after the renewal?

May 12, 2017
Location pin iconMeridian, FL

I had to renew my car insurance, forgot the date, and renewed the next day. One day later I found ...