is a privately owned website that publishes unbiased rates and carrier information for consumer benefit. Learn More

Preferred Mutual Car Insurance

When you purchase auto insurance, you’re not only protecting your vehicle - you’re protecting your lifestyle; that's why Preferred Mutual is committed to giving you the best protection you deserve.

Compare rates from the top car insurance companies in your area.

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.

Car Insurance Wiki

What we know about Preferred Mutual

Preferred Mutual, headquartered in the great city of New Berlin, NY, was founded in 1896. Its financial strength rating–aka its money-flexing muscle power to keep your assets safe–is Excellent. On the other hand, its J.D. Power rating, which measures customer satisfaction around the handling of claims, is Not Rated out of 5. A higher J.D. Power Rating is a good indicator that a carrier will treat you well should something go wrong. Which is exactly what insurance is for, right? See more on J.D. Power ratings here.




Claims Rating


User Satisfaction

Preferred Mutual Auto Insurance Discounts & Features

  • Defensive Driver Discount
  • Good Student Discount
  • Multi-Policy Discount
  • Safe Cars Discount
  • Motor Club Discount
  • Manage Your Policy Online
  • Report Claims Online
  • 24x7 Support
  • e-Billing Options
  • Accident Forgiveness
  • Towing & Labor
  • Rental Reimbursement
  • Trip Interruption

Around the Web

About The Zebra

The Zebra is not an insurance company. We’re an independent agency on a mission to help you compare all of your insurance options apples-to-apples, so you can make a truly informed decision. We’re proud because:

  • We’re the first to compare all the major car insurance companies side-by-side. The information provided on those insurers here is intended to help inform and educate consumers before they decide where to spend their hard-earned cash.
  • We’re independent. We have no stake in which insurance company you choose; we simply want to offer you unbiased, fast, side-by-side comparisons of your car insurance options.