What's the Average Cost of Car Insurance in New York City?


New York state's premiums are relatively equivalent to the national mean: within $32 of the nationwide average. Let's take a look at how auto insurance costs in New York City specifically compare to rates nation- and state-wide.


CAR INSURANCE RATES: NYC VS. US AND STATE AVERAGES
City AverageState AverageNational Average
$2,814$1,537$1,569


New York City Car Insurance With Accidents or Violations


By knowing which driving mishaps can spike your insurance rates, you can make better decisions and save money. Drivers with a DUI in New York City endure car insurance costs nearly double the citywide average. Reckless driving will also bump your premiums up, with average rates of $4,502, which are 60% higher than the city average! Compared to at-fault accidents with damages of less than $1,000, accidents with damages exceeding $2,000 cost drivers an additional $916 per year in premiums.


AVERAGE NEW YORK INSURANCE RATES AFTER A VIOLATION OR ACCIDENT
Violation/IncidentMean Rate
DUI$5,219
Reckless Driving$4,502
At-fault Accident (damages less than $1,000)$2,929
At-fault Accident (damages greater than $2,000)$3,846
Speeding Ticket (16-20 mph over speed limit)$3,252


New York Car Insurance by Credit Rating


Improving your credit score from the Very Poor tier (300-579) to the Exceptional tier (800-850) can save you an average of 61% each year on car insurance in the five boroughs. In terms of percent change, the most significant benefit of better credit comes from boosting from Very Poor (300-579) to Fair (580-669), by which drivers can save nearly 44% per year.


NEW YORK AUTO INSURANCE COSTS BY CREDIT TIER
Credit QualityAverage Auto Insurance Rate
Very Poor$6,244
Fair$3,466
Good$2,814
Very Good$2,609
Exceptional$2,433


New York Auto Insurance Rates by Age

Car insurance premiums are highest for teenage drivers, with payments that average $9,287 per year. Drivers in their 70s save money on insurance payments, as they have the smallest rates among all age groups, paying only $2,386 annually. The biggest fall in premiums for New York drivers happens when they hit their 20s. Once out of the teenage age bracket, drivers save, on average, $6,901. Insurance rates continue to trend downward up until drivers turn 60.


NEW YORK CAR INSURANCE PRICES BY DRIVER AGE
AgeAverage Rate
Teenagers$9,287
20s$3,697
30s$2,801
40s$2,712
50s$2,656
60s$2,748
70s$2,386


New York Car Insurance by Gender and Marital Status


Auto insurance premiums in New York are influenced by driver traits such as gender and marital status. For those who are widowed or divorced, rates are slightly cheaper than rates for those who are single. Being single, as opposed to married, can cost you an average of 3% more per year on car insurance. $96 is the amount by which men's and women's car insurance premiums vary.


NEW YORK CAR INSURANCE RATES BY GENDER AND MARITAL STATUS
Marital Status/GenderAverage Rate
Female$2,909
Male$2,814
Single$1,385
Married$1,344
Divorced$1,366
Widowed$1,366


What raises car insurance rates in New York City?

Where you live in New York affects your car insurance rates. Besides your driving history and credit score, where you live is one of the biggest contributing factors to the car insurance rates you'll pay. The reason? Crime, theft and uninsured motorists vary by zip code. So if you find yourself in a neighborhood that doesn’t play well with others, car insurance companies may consider you a high risk to insure, meaning: your rates could be higher than those of a pal who lives just around the block. And, unfortunately New York is no exception to the rule. From zip code 10004 to 11212, premiums rise by 94 percent—that’s $2041.

Expensive New York Zip Codes: 11208, 11203, 11236, 11233, 11212

Cheap New York Zip Codes: 10004, 10280, 10001, 10003, 10007

New York Driving Conditions

Inclement weather goes hand in hand with wet brakes, slick roads & decreased visibility.

And that's not the worst of it. Each year there are more than 700,000 weather-related car accidents. In New York, you can expect 122 rainy days with an annual rainfall of 49.9 inches. New York is also known to experience severe winter storms. You can check on the condition of the roads anytime here.

122

Rainy Days a Year

50"

Avg. Annual Rainfall

25"

Avg. Annual Snowfall

Be Prepared For

Driving in NYC

2
Major Highways
I-87 I-78 I-95
2
2
Toll Roads
Robert F. Kennedy Bridge Gov. Thomas E. Dewey Thruway Marine Parkway - Gill Hodges Memorial Bridge
2
Popular Day Trips
Montauk Fire Island Cold Spring

Find Local New York City Agents

Kenneth Bieber Inc

370 Lexington Ave New York, NY 10017

Campbell Solberg Associates, Inc.

110 William St New York, NY 10038

The Magrino Agency

9729 4th Ave Ste A Brooklyn, NY 11209

Argyle Insurance Agency, LLC

71 West 47th Street, Suite#1002 New York, NY 10036

Marchetti & Sabatelli Associates, Inc.

9201 4th Ave, 2nd Floor Brooklyn, NY 11209

Not sure about New York

Check out these other cities in New York state:

Buffalo

2

$2,761

The average New Yorker's annual cost of coverage

2

40%

Our customer's average savings after comparing insurance

Revised

442

That's equal to 442 pieces of thin crust or $1,104 in savings

See How Much You Can Save in New York

Just enter your zip code to get started

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.

Recent Questions:

New York City Car Insurance

If I'm looking to get renters insurance on a short-term Airbnb rental, what's the best way to go about it?

I certainly understand your concern, but you cannot get a renters policy for an Airbnb you are temporarily residing in. If you have a renters policy for your current address, your liability coverage will cover any damage you cause to the Airbnb (up to your liability limit).

What are my options if I am paying over $700 a month in car insurance?

Unfortunately, it would appear that your girlfriend's insurance company sees her as a high-risk driver. This would explain her coverage being dropped and the new policy having expensive rates.

How can I enroll just my child to another insurance policy while I stay with Geico?

This can be tricky. My best recommendation is simply to contact GEICO.

How does HO-2 coverage compare with an HO-5 policy?

An HO-2 policy provides very basic coverage for your home and personal property. It covers the home when the damage is caused by specifically named events (perils).