North Star vs. Erie Car Insurance

Compare rates from the top car insurance companies in your area.

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.

North Star Mutual or Erie:
Which Company is Best for You?

Choosing a car insurance company is sometimes difficult: companies' rates vary based on your driving record, age, and location, and insurers offer a variety of perks. North Star and Erie are two of the most popular insurers, providing high-quality policies in most states.

To simplify the process of comparing insurance companies, we've collected average rates from Erie and North Star. These cover a variety of pricing factors, including credit rating, driving infractions, and demographics. Check out the below rates and find the right policy for you.


North Star vs. Erie: insurance rate comparison


North Star vs. Erie: pricing by credit score

If you have very poor credit, North Star could be a better option for you. On average, North Star offers more affordable rates than Erie for drivers with credit scores of less than 580. Insurance shoppers with outstanding credit — a score of 800-plus — should lean toward View common insurance rates by credit score for Erie and North Star below.


RATES BY CREDIT LEVEL: ERIE VS. NORTH STAR
Credit levelNorth Star avg. annual premiumErie avg. annual premium
Very Poor (300-579)$1,980$2,402
Fair (580-669)$1,405$1,040
Good (670-739)$1,256$894
Very Good (740-799)$1,018$743
Exceptional (800-850)$962$726

North Star vs. Erie: rates for drivers with bad records

If you're dealing with an at-fault crash, ticket, reckless driving violation, or DUI on your driving résumé, Erie could be a better choice than North Star. Each car insurance company prices policies differently after a violation, so it's worth comparing quotes to find out which insurer suits you.


RATES BY CITATION: ERIE VS. NORTH STAR
InfractionNorth Star avg. annual premiumErie avg. annual premium
At-fault accident (damage < $1,000)$1,534$893
At-fault accident (damage > $1,000)$1,534$772
DUI/DWI$3,221$1,163
Reckless driving$2,339$760
Speeding ticket$1,516$747

North Star vs. Erie: rates by age

Insurers rely on a driver's age to estimate risk, pricing policies accordingly. An auto insurance policy is commonly more expensive for teens — because of their inexperience — and relatively affordable for middle-aged drivers. Because every insurance company rates age brackets uniquely, it's smart to shop around and find the perfect policy for you.

As a general rule, teen drivers should choose Erie over North Star: the former's average annual rates are $500 less than the latter's..


RATES BY AGE BRACKET: ERIE VS. NORTH STAR
Age tierNorth Star avg. annual premiumErie avg. annual premium
Teens$2,738$2,238
20s$1,454$1,108
30s$1,074$1,108
40s$1,074$755
50s$825$692
60s$822$676

Finances aside, there are myriad pros and cons of both North Star and Erie, including their discount programs, add-ons, customer satisfaction ratings, and financial stability. Be sure to weigh these elements before deciding.

Discount ComparisonNorth Star MutualErie
Good Student
Multiple Policies
Multiple Vehicles
Anti-Theft Device(s)
Anti-Lock Brake System
Air Bags
Good Driver
Defensive Driver
Student Away at School
Driver Training
Green Vehicles
Affinity Membership Alum
Advanced Purchase
Pay in Full
Home Owner
eSign or ePay
Telematics
New Vehicle
Annual Mileage
Military
Ratings ComparisonNorth Star MutualErie
Financial Strength SuperiorSuperior
JD Power Rankings Not Rated
100% filled Star icon 100% filled Star icon 100% filled Star icon 100% filled Star icon 100% filled Star icon
5 out of 5
User Satisfaction

A+

A+

Other ProductsNorth Star MutualErie
Boat Insurance
Condo Insurance
Life Insurance
Homeowners Insurance
Travel Trailer Insurance
Renters Insurance
RV Insurance
Motorcycle Insurance
Mobile Home Insurance
Other FeaturesNorth Star MutualErie
AboutNorth Star Mutual provides insurance protection through a variety of products along with friendly personal service and fast, hassle-free claims handling to keep you on course.Erie Insurance provides customers with the flexibility to customize their car insurance by offering over 30 extra policy features, along with the highest levels of customer service.
Roadside AssistanceNorth Star Mutual offers 24-hour emergency roadside assistance, including towing, tire, battery, delivery, and locksmith services, as well as mechanical first aid.Erie provides 24-hour roadside assistance for an additional fee on your policy that covers reasonable auto towing and required labor cost at the site of your vehicle breakdown.
Additional DiscountsNone AvailableErie offers an additional discount called "Reduced Usage" that provides a lower rate on your policy if your vehicle is unused for 90 consecutive days during the policy period.
Recent QuestionsWill Erie reinstate my policy after non-payment?

I have had Erie for 31 years..2 home owners and also auto...

I was injured in a car accident two months ago, can I still file a claim?

I was rear ended and didn’t go to the hospital. That was two months ago. Now I can barely walk. ...

How long can an insurance company wait to pay out your claim?

In Virginia, is there a time limit on how long after a car accident an insurance company can wait to ...

If the person who damaged my vehicle is paying for the repair out of pocket, will the claim show up anywhere on my record?

Someone dented the hood of my car by standing on it. I got a repair estimate of $500 and the ...

See More Questions
Compare MoreNorth Star Mutual vs. 21st Century North Star Mutual vs. Allied North Star Mutual vs. Allstate North Star Mutual vs. American Family North Star Mutual vs. Amica Mutual Insurance North Star Mutual vs. Auto Club (AAA) North Star Mutual vs. Farm Bureau Mutual North Star Mutual vs. Farmers North Star Mutual vs. GEICO North Star Mutual vs. Infinity North Star Mutual vs. Liberty Mutual North Star Mutual vs. Mercury North Star Mutual vs. MetLife North Star Mutual vs. Nationwide North Star Mutual vs. Progressive North Star Mutual vs. SAFECO North Star Mutual vs. Safe Auto North Star Mutual vs. State FarmErie vs. 21st Century Erie vs. Allied Erie vs. Allstate Erie vs. American Family Erie vs. Amica Mutual Insurance Erie vs. Auto Club (AAA) Erie vs. Esurance Erie vs. Farm Bureau Mutual Erie vs. Farmers Erie vs. Foremost Erie vs. GEICO Erie vs. Infinity Erie vs. Liberty Mutual Erie vs. Mercury Erie vs. MetLife Erie vs. Nationwide Erie vs. Progressive Erie vs. SAFECO Erie vs. Safe Auto Erie vs. State Farm Erie vs. The General Erie vs. The Hartford Erie vs. Titan Erie vs. Travelers Erie vs. USAA
States OfferedMinnesota North Dakota South Dakota Nebraska Oklahoma Iowa Kansas WisconsinIllinois Indiana Kentucky Maryland New York North Carolina Ohio Pennsylvania Tennessee Virginia
Additional Resources:

North Star vs. Erie

Chevron left icon
Survey: Americans in the Dark about Car Insurance
Survey: Americans in the Dark about Car Insurance
Oct 24, 2017

“What you don’t know can’t hurt you…” … is an entirely false statement in the world of auto insurance. Car...

Editorial: A Need for Optionality in Insurance
Editorial: A Need for Optionality in Insurance
Sep 19, 2017

Today The Zebra announced that we closed a record-breaking $40 million Series B funding round, led by Accel Partners. As...

InsurTech Trends: Industry Experts Discuss Which Are Truly Innovative
InsurTech Trends: Industry Experts Discuss Which Are Truly Innovative
Aug 28, 2017

Insurance technology (also known as InsurTech or InsureTech) is en vogue. Whether it’s a new model of underwriting or new...

Why Tesla is Opting to Insure Its Own Cars
Why Tesla is Opting to Insure Its Own Cars
Apr 13, 2017

As driverless vehicles become less a futuristic dream and more a reality, our current system – which is obviously based...

How Does the Government Affect What You Pay for Car Insurance?
How Does the Government Affect What You Pay for Car Insurance?
Mar 12, 2017

  With auto insurance rates on the rise over the last five years, I’m constantly asked who’s responsible for auto...

Don’t Count on Anti-Theft Devices to Lower Your Insurance Rate – Here’s Why
Don’t Count on Anti-Theft Devices to Lower Your Insurance Rate – Here’s Why
Nov 02, 2016

We know that tech and automotive companies are racing to create increasingly connected, autonomous cars. In fact, many of us...

The Strangest Insurance Policies We’ve Ever Heard Of
The Strangest Insurance Policies We’ve Ever Heard Of
Sep 16, 2016

At The Zebra, insurance is our bread and butter. But in this enormous and complicated industry, there are lines of...

It’s Not You… Or Is It? What Might Cause Your Insurance Company to Drop You
It’s Not You… Or Is It? What Might Cause Your Insurance Company to Drop You
Jul 05, 2016

Car insurance companies may occasionally cancel policies if customers fail to pay the premium, commit insurance fraud, make unapproved modifications that change the...

The Absurd Spectrum of Auto Insurance Fraud
The Absurd Spectrum of Auto Insurance Fraud
May 24, 2016

Far from a victimless crime perpetuated against bloated corporations, insurance fraud reaches into the lives of everyday citizens. It costs the industry...

When Does a Little White Lie Become Insurance Fraud?
When Does a Little White Lie Become Insurance Fraud?
May 09, 2016

In the U.S., drivers are legally required to carry auto insurance. (Even in New Hampshire, the only state where drivers...

Why Your Auto Insurance Rates Could Be Rising This Year
Why Your Auto Insurance Rates Could Be Rising This Year
Feb 01, 2016

Rate increase? Click to find the cheapest rates on car insurance →   Lower gas prices = more road traffic...

Editorial: A Need for Transparency in Car Insurance
Editorial: A Need for Transparency in Car Insurance
Jan 26, 2016

By Alyssa Connolly, The Zebra We have exciting news on The Zebra front! Today we announced that we closed $17...

Will Insurance Companies Turn to Social Media to Assess Your Risk?
Will Insurance Companies Turn to Social Media to Assess Your Risk?
Oct 21, 2015

In the week following October 10, a story of law enforcement cracking down on a drunk driver spread quickly across...

Move Over Millennials: The Auto Industry is Interested in Your Grandparents
Move Over Millennials: The Auto Industry is Interested in Your Grandparents
Oct 16, 2015

The defining characteristics of the 80 million young people currently between the ages 18 and 34 has been much debated....

Drive Less, Pay Less? The Truth About Mileage and Car Insurance
Drive Less, Pay Less? The Truth About Mileage and Car Insurance
Sep 15, 2015

Driving fewer miles can mean insurance premium savings—for some people with some insurance carriers. So how much less must you...

How to Get Car Insurance for Undocumented Citizens
How to Get Car Insurance for Undocumented Citizens
Aug 27, 2015

Purchasing car insurance: for US citizens, it’s often a rather mundane chore—something that whittles away at disposable income, but without...

Car Insurance Scams: Are You A Target?
Car Insurance Scams: Are You A Target?
Aug 10, 2015

Sometimes things aren’t what they seem at the scene of a car crash, or even on the repair shop floor....

Insurance Telematics USA 2015: A Conference Looking to the Future
Insurance Telematics USA 2015: A Conference Looking to the Future
Jul 07, 2015

Pop quiz: What’s the largest potential technological disrupter of the car insurance industry? (Besides The Zebra, of course.) Answer: telematics....

When Traffic Tickets Cause Insurance Premiums to Rise
When Traffic Tickets Cause Insurance Premiums to Rise
Jun 30, 2015

A traffic ticket of any kind is bad enough—the extra money, the time spent in traffic court or diversion, the...

Could Your Voting Record Affect Your Car Insurance Rates?
Could Your Voting Record Affect Your Car Insurance Rates?
Jun 12, 2015

Anyone who’s ever searched for an auto insurance company knows by the questions they’re asked—plentiful and at times personal—that a...

Should Price Optimization Be Illegal?
Should Price Optimization Be Illegal?
Feb 23, 2015

If you haven’t had a car accident or made an insurance claim recently, you probably only think about your car...

This Guy Could Revolutionize Insurance Company Reviews
This Guy Could Revolutionize Insurance Company Reviews
Jul 24, 2014

You just can’t try insurance before you buy it—not really. You can read car insurance company reviews via some online...

Chevron right icon