How Technology is Changing the Face of Insurance Fraud

From new scams to enhanced fraud detection

Author profile picture

Bob Phillips

Personal Finance Writer

Bob Phillips is a personal finance writer whose expertise in insurance and investments has been developed through over fifteen years as an advisor/tr…

Author profile picture

Ross Martin

Insurance Writer

Credentials
  • 4+ years in the Insurance Industry

Ross joined The Zebra as a writer and researcher in 2019. He specializes in writing insurance content to help shoppers make informed decisions.

Ross h…

Author profile picture

Susan Meyer

Senior Editorial Manager

Credentials
  • Licensed Insurance Agent — Property and Casualty

Susan is a licensed insurance agent and has worked as a writer and editor for over 10 years across a number of industries. She has worked at The Zebr…

Insurance fraud is a persistent issue that costs the industry over $300 billion annually, but with advancements in technology—particularly artificial intelligence (AI)—the landscape is rapidly changing.[1]

In the past, insurance fraud relied heavily on manual efforts from both fraudsters and insurance companies. Fraudsters would fabricate claims, exaggerate damages or stage accidents while insurance companies deployed teams of investigators to sift through mountains of paperwork to find red flags.

However, the rise of AI, machine learning and other technological tools is reshaping both the ways fraud is committed and how it is detected.

The Evolution of Insurance Fraud Scams with Technology

With the advent of AI and automation, fraudsters have found new, more sophisticated methods to commit fraud. Digital tools have made it easier to manipulate data, fake identities and create false documentation. Below are some examples of how technology is being leveraged by those on the wrong side of the law:

1. Deepfakes and Synthetic Identities 

AI-powered deepfake technology, which can manipulate audio, video and images, allows fraudsters to create entirely new "people" with synthetic identities. By using deepfakes, fraudsters can bypass traditional verification systems, submitting claims as fake individuals with convincing credentials. These synthetic identities are often built using a combination of stolen personal information and fabricated data.

2. Phishing and Cyber Attacks 

Fraudsters use AI-driven phishing attacks to access sensitive insurance data. Machine learning algorithms can analyze millions of emails and user profiles, allowing scammers to tailor phishing emails to specific targets. This leads to identity theft, which can then be used to file fraudulent claims or steal payouts.

3. Exaggeration of Damage

AI allows fraudsters to manipulate images of damage to vehicles, homes or other insured property. By using image-enhancing tools and editing software, they can make minor damage appear far worse than it actually is, inflating the value of the claim. Additionally, AI-generated estimates can help fraudsters justify exaggerated repair costs.

4. Social Engineering with AI 

Fraudsters are increasingly using AI to collect data on insurance policyholders through social engineering. By analyzing social media and other digital footprints, fraudsters can gather personal details, such as health information, family circumstances or travel plans, which they then use to fabricate claims.

The sheer speed and volume at which fraudsters can operate have been magnified by these technological advancements. Unlike the traditional, slow-moving tactics of old, today’s scams can be orchestrated and executed in a matter of minutes.

How Technology is Fighting Back: AI in Fraud Detection

While technology has given fraudsters new weapons, it’s also helping insurance companies fight back. AI and machine learning, in particular, are becoming indispensable tools in fraud detection and prevention. By leveraging vast amounts of data, AI can quickly identify suspicious patterns, flag potentially fraudulent claims and assist human investigators in narrowing down cases worth examining.

Here’s how technology is revolutionizing fraud detection:

1. Data Analysis and Pattern Recognition 

Traditional fraud detection often relied on manual oversight, where investigators had to sift through claims one at a time, looking for anomalies. AI, on the other hand, can analyze millions of claims in real time. Machine learning models are designed to detect unusual patterns in claims data that may indicate fraud. For example, AI can recognize repeated claims for the same type of damage from the same person or identify multiple claims from different individuals for the same incident.

2. Natural Language Processing (NLP)

AI-powered NLP tools are being deployed to analyze the text within insurance claims, emails and even recorded phone calls between policyholders and insurance agents. These tools can identify inconsistencies, contradictions or language that deviates from normal patterns, which may suggest fraudulent intent. For example, if a person files a claim for a stolen car but inconsistencies appear in their description of the event across different documents, NLP algorithms can flag that claim for further investigation.

3. Predictive Analytics

AI systems can leverage predictive analytics to assess the likelihood that a claim is fraudulent before it is even processed. By analyzing historical data, the algorithms can create profiles of known fraudsters and identify common traits or actions that tend to precede fraudulent claims. For example, if a policyholder has a history of frequently switching policies or filing multiple small claims, the AI system might flag their account as high-risk.

4. Biometrics and Voice Recognition 

Some insurance companies are now incorporating biometric technology into their customer service and claims processes. AI-powered voice recognition can be used during phone calls to identify emotional cues or vocal stress patterns that may suggest deception. Additionally, biometric security measures such as facial recognition and fingerprint scanning make it more difficult for fraudsters to submit claims using stolen or fabricated identities.

5. Automated Image Analysis

AI-driven image recognition tools can automatically analyze photographs of damage or injuries submitted as part of a claim. These systems can detect inconsistencies in images that may suggest they have been altered or enhanced. For example, AI might analyze the lighting, shadows or object placement in a photograph to determine if an image has been manipulated. This not only helps prevent fraud but also speeds up the claims process for genuine policyholders.

AI-Driven Collaboration and Industry-Wide Databases

In addition to its direct role in fraud detection, AI is enabling greater collaboration between insurance companies through shared databases and industry-wide platforms. Insurance companies can now pool their data into centralized AI-powered systems, which allow for real-time sharing of information about fraud cases and suspicious claims. This level of collaboration has proven especially valuable in detecting "serial fraudsters" who attempt to commit fraud across multiple insurers. 

For example, if a fraudster files a fraudulent claim with one insurer and then tries to do the same with another, the AI system will alert both companies. This cross-company collaboration also helps reduce the amount of time fraudsters can operate before being detected.

The Benefits of AI-Powered Fraud Detection for Policyholders

What does this mean for you as a policyholder? 

While the primary focus of AI-powered fraud detection is to reduce losses for insurance companies, the benefits extend to policyholders as well. As fraud becomes harder to perpetrate, the overall costs associated with fraud—costs that are often passed on to policyholders in the form of higher premiums—are reduced. By reducing fraud, insurance companies can keep premiums more affordable and allocate resources more efficiently.

Additionally, the increased efficiency of AI in fraud detection helps speed up legitimate claims processing. Instead of spending weeks or months investigating claims, insurers can quickly resolve straightforward cases while focusing investigative resources on high-risk claims. This leads to a better overall customer experience for policyholders who are making honest claims.

zebra shield icon
Learn more about car insurance fraud, how to report it, and how to prevent it.

The Future of Fraud Detection: Challenges and Opportunities

Despite the significant progress AI and other technologies have made in combating insurance fraud, there are still challenges on the horizon. As technology continues to evolve, so too will the tactics employed by fraudsters. Insurers will need to stay one step ahead, continually updating their AI systems and investing in new fraud detection technologies.

Another challenge lies in balancing the use of AI with privacy concerns. While AI requires large amounts of data to function effectively, insurance companies must be careful to protect their customers' personal information and comply with data protection laws. Finding the right balance between utilizing technology and maintaining trust with policyholders will be crucial for the future.

Wrapping up

Technology, especially AI, has dramatically reshaped the world of insurance fraud. While fraudsters are using increasingly sophisticated methods to exploit the system, AI is providing insurance companies with the tools to fight back more effectively than ever before. 

By automating fraud detection, analyzing vast amounts of data, and identifying suspicious patterns in real time, AI is not only reducing the financial impact of fraud but also improving the overall experience for policyholders. As both fraudsters and insurers continue to adopt new technologies, the battle against insurance fraud will remain an ongoing challenge, but one that is increasingly tilted in favor of those working to keep the system honest.