Ask an Agent
Have a question? We're here to help.
Ask an agent for free

Worth paying $1,800 out of pocket to avoid an increase in auto insurance premiums?

I was in a fender bender recently and the estimate for the other guys' car repair is around $1700-1800. I already have an accident on my file from 1 year ago (October 2017) which made my premium go up from $600 to $900 per 3 months and I'm worried this could push it even further. Is it worth paying out of pocket or should I bring it to my insurance to cover ($500 deductible). To be honest, I repaired my car for only $100 because I am OK with cosmetic damage to the bumper, but I understand why he would want to get his bumper replaced because it is my fault, and he has a right to have it restored to the way it was before the accident.

Aug 18, 2018 San Diego, CA

Author profile picture

Ava Lynch

Insurance Analyst

  • 7+ years of Experience in the Insurance Industry

Ava joined The Zebra as a writer and licensed insurance agent in 2016. She now works as a senior insurance contributor, providing insights and data a…

There are a few things to consider.

  1. First, most insurance companies require you to report any incident, even if a claim is not filed.
  2. Filing a claim will impact your insurance rates. Check out our article on the claims process which will explain the things to consider when deciding whether to file a claim.
  3. Next, in 2020, an at-fault accident increased a driver's insurance premium by an average of 45% meaning drivers would pay $3k+ in premium increases over five years. A second at-fault accident would certainly further increase your premium. If you can afford to pay out of pocket for the damages, it can be cheaper in the long run than having your insurance rates impacted for the next five years. 
  4. However, the person you hit might not want you to pay out of pocket and would prefer to handle it through the insurance company. This is why you need to report the incident to your insurance company as soon as possible.

Also, your deductible would not be applied in this situation since you would not be having your car repaired. Your liability coverage would cover the damages to the other car. If you did file a claim to have your car repaired then your deductible for collision coverage would apply. Check out our page on what you can expect when filing a claim. Good luck and if you have any other questions, don't hesitate to ask.  

Ask an Agent
Have a question? We're here to help.
Ask an agent for free

Insurance is complicated, but it doesn't have to be.

The Zebra searches all of the top insurance companies, in one place, so you can compare the cost and coverage you need to protect your car, home and other property.

Step 1: Tell us a little about yourself

Choose an insurance product and enter your zip code to get started.

Step 2: Sip your coffee while we find the best quotes

Enter the necessary information and then sit back while we find quotes from 100 top insurance carriers.

Icon Fill Form

Step 3: Compare your quotes

Compare quotes side-by-side to find the right match for you, whether it's home, auto, or more.

Icon Agent

Step 4: Let our agents do the hard work for you

Once you pick your policy, our agents are here to get you over the finish line. Then just relax and enjoy your savings.

Compare insurance rates today!

Location pin icon
No junk mail. No spam calls. Free quotes.

Related Questions

Other people are also asking...

If I sell my car and cancel my insurance, will my rates be higher later on?

You are right — having a lapse in coverage will cause your rates to be higher in the future. I recommend getting a non-owners policy, which it sounds like Progressive is already offering to you. This is essentially a liability-only policy when you do not own a vehicle, or are between vehicle owners…
May 22, 2019 Los Angeles, CA

How far back do insurance companies look?

Great question! While it can vary by carrier, most car insurance companies will charge (i.e. increase your premium) for any ticket or violation within the past 3 years. You typically won't be charged for anything that happened beyond three years ago, however, insurance companies will still pul…
Feb 20, 2018 Middletown, CT

How do I handle an accident where the person I hit is claiming more damage than what was actually caused?

If you are filing a claim with your insurance company then the simplest solution is to provide them with pictures of the damage from the accident scene. They will investigate the accident and pay for any damage for which you are liable. Whether or not they cover the damaged tail light will not make…
Jul 30, 2017 Kent, WA

What do I do if my car is hit by an object that came off of someone else's vehicle?

Filing a police report and contacting your insurance provider would be my recommendation. Doing this allows the police to search for the driver pulling the trailer while your insurance company starts the repair process on your vehicle. The driver of the truck should be responsible, but it may be di…
Sep 24, 2016 Manteno, IL