Resource Center Next Car

Is It Legal to Not Use Insurance if You Have It?

Understanding out-of-pocket options for auto, home and health insurance

Author profile picture
By Susan Meyer Info icon
Updated November 8, 2024
Author profile picture

Susan Meyer

Senior Editorial Manager

Credentials
  • Licensed Insurance Agent — Property and Casualty

Susan is a licensed insurance agent and has worked as a writer and editor for over 10 years across a number of industries. She has worked at The Zebr…

View full profile Right arrow icon
Author profile picture

Ross Martin

Insurance Writer

Credentials
  • 5+ years in the Insurance Industry

Ross joined The Zebra as a writer and researcher in 2019. He specializes in writing insurance content to help shoppers make informed decisions.

Ross h…

View full profile Right arrow icon
Jump to Chevron down icon
  1. Auto insurance
  2. Home insurance
  3. Health insurance

If you’re paying for insurance every month — whether because it’s required or for peace of mind — it often makes sense to use it when something happens. After all, insurance is a tool designed to protect us from significant financial burdens when unavoidable perils come our way.

However, there are times when paying out-of-pocket, even when you have insurance, may seem appealing. Sometimes it’s to avoid rate hikes or if you have a high deductible. The decision to sidestep insurance claims, whether for health, auto or home repairs, is worth careful consideration. And is it legal?

Read on for our breakdown of the legality, motivations and potential drawbacks of choosing not to use insurance even when you’re covered.

Auto insurance

In the U.S., nearly all states mandate some form of liability insurance to cover damage or injury to others if you’re at fault in an accident. If you're legally obligated to have auto insurance, it’s illegal to refuse to use it for at-fault accidents or damages involving another party. 

However, if you’re in a minor single-car accident, you may have the option to pay out of pocket for repairs instead of making an insurance claim.

Reasons to pay out of pocket for auto insurance

Avoiding rising premiums

Filing a claim may increase your rates, especially if you’ve filed multiple claims within a short period.

Preserving insurance benefits

Some insurers limit your options or coverage if they perceive a high risk from frequent claims.

Small damages below deductible

For minor dings and scratches, it can be more affordable to pay directly rather than through insurance if costs fall under your deductible.

Drawbacks and considerations

Legal requirements in multi-party incidents

If another party is involved, liability coverage typically mandates the use of insurance.

Policy violations

Some policies require you to report accidents to maintain coverage, even if you choose not to file a claim.

Unpredictable repair costs

Minor damages might reveal hidden issues requiring expensive repairs, ultimately costing more than your deductible.

Home insurance and home repairs

When it comes to homeowners insurance, it’s generally legal to pay for repairs out of pocket. Homeowners insurance is not mandated by law, although mortgage lenders typically require it as a condition for financing. However, the decision to use or not use your policy for repairs should be considered carefully, especially if it impacts the home’s safety or structural integrity.

Reasons to pay out of pocket for home insurance

Preserving discounts

Some homeowners insurance policies offer discounts for customers who remain claim-free over several years.

Minor repairs

Fixing small issues (like replacing a broken window or patching drywall) can often be done inexpensively without involving insurance.

Avoiding high premiums

Filing frequent claims can raise premiums, so paying out of pocket for minor incidents may save money in the long run.

Drawbacks and considerations

Risk of underestimating damage

A small leak may seem minor but can lead to severe water damage over time, potentially invalidating future claims.

Insurer's right to non-renew

Some insurers might non-renew policies after certain types of damage if they’re not informed of the repairs.

Compliance with loan agreements

Mortgage lenders may require you to report damages and file claims for certain incidents to protect their collateral in the home.

Paying out of pocket for health insurance

In most cases, it’s not illegal to pay out of pocket for health services instead of using your insurance. Medical providers generally accept cash payments, and the law doesn’t mandate that you use your insurance for every visit or procedure. 

However, certain health plans, especially those with employer contributions or government assistance (such as Medicare and Medicaid), may have specific guidelines or restrictions on out-of-pocket payments for covered services. If your health insurance is government-subsidized, choosing to pay out of pocket for covered services might require additional steps or disclosures.

Reasons to pay out of pocket for healthcare

Privacy concerns

Some people prefer to keep certain treatments off the record with their insurer, especially for sensitive treatments.

High deductibles

If you haven’t met your deductible, you may opt to pay out of pocket, as it won’t impact your insurance until the deductible is met.

Provider preferences

Some doctors or specialists don’t accept specific insurance plans, so paying out of pocket can grant you access to them.

Drawbacks and considerations

Loss of accumulated benefits

Certain health plans offer perks like loyalty discounts or coverage of wellness visits based on your ongoing use of their services.

Potential insurance limitations

If your insurance requires referrals, seeing providers out-of-pocket could complicate your eligibility for other covered services.

Higher costs in emergencies

While paying out of pocket for routine visits may not be an issue, uninsured costs can skyrocket in an emergency or hospital admission.

Wrapping up

In most cases, it’s not illegal to pay out of pocket even if you have insurance, though legal obligations vary by policy type. Understanding the nuances and potential consequences can help you make informed decisions that protect both your finances and compliance with your insurance agreements. 

In general, opting for out-of-pocket payments works best for minor or routine expenses. For significant incidents, relying on insurance can provide the necessary protection and peace of mind that insurance was designed to offer.