When Accidents Happen at Home: Fault, Liability, and Coverage Explained

The 5 Most Common Household Accidents

Author profile picture

Susan Meyer

Senior Editorial Manager

Susan is a licensed insurance agent and has worked as a writer and editor for over 10 years across a number of industries. She has worked at The Zebr…

Credentials
  • Licensed Insurance Agent — Property and Casualty
Author profile picture

Beth Swanson

Insurance Analyst

Beth joined The Zebra in 2022 as an Associate Content Strategist. A licensed insurance agent, she specializes in creating clear, accessible content t…

Credentials
  • Licensed Insurance Agent — Property and Casualty
  • Associate in Insurance (AINS)
  • Professional Risk Consultant (PRC)
  • Associate in Insurance Services (AIS)

Home Is Where the Accidents Are

Home is supposed to be the safest place in the world, yet it’s also where many accidents happen. From slips on wet floors to accidental burns in the kitchen, household injuries are surprisingly common, and sometimes severe. According to the National Security Council, in one year, there are 125,700 deaths and 35 million medically consulted injuries due to preventable household accidents.[1]

When an injury happens to a guest, it’s not just a health concern, but also a legal and financial one.

In many cases, homeowners insurance or renters insurance can help cover medical expenses or legal costs if you’re found liable. But the rules vary depending on the situation, the cause and the policy details.

Let’s look at five of the most common household accidents, who might be at fault, and how insurance typically responds.

1. Falls

Falls are one of the most common household accidents, especially on slippery floors, icy driveways, loose rugs or poorly lit staircases.

Each year, more than 8 million people in the U.S. visit the emergency room because of fall-related injuries, and over 20% of those involve serious harm such as fractures or head trauma. In fact, falls are the leading cause of traumatic brain injury.[2]

Who’s at fault?

If the homeowner or tenant knew, or should have known, about the hazard and didn’t take reasonable steps to fix it, they may be liable. For example, ignoring a broken handrail for weeks could point to negligence. On the other hand, if the guest ignored warnings or acted recklessly, the fault might be shared.

Insurance coverage

Most homeowners or renters policies include liability coverage that pays for medical bills and legal expenses if a guest is injured and you’re found responsible. Many policies also offer medical payments coverage, which pays for minor injuries to guests regardless of fault.

Preventing Falls

Falls are nearly 100% preventable accidents. Here's how you can you make your home safer:

  • Keep floors and surfaces free of clutter.
  • Keep cabinets and drawers closed when not in use.
  • Avoid having phone or electrical cords running through traffic areas.
  • Install handrails on interior and exterior stairways.
  • Never stand on furniture with wheels and practice good ladder safety.
  • Arrange furniture to create open pathways.
  • Maintain good interior and exterior lighting.

2. Poisoning

Poisoning in the home isn’t always about malicious intent; it often comes down to accidental ingestion. Cleaning products left under the sink, prescription medications in easy reach, or even certain houseplants can pose a risk, especially for children.

Poison control centers handle over 2 million poisoning cases in the U.S. each year, and a significant number happen in residential settings.[3]

Who's at fault?

If the dangerous substance was not stored safely and a guest, or their child, was harmed, the homeowner could be held responsible. This is particularly true if they failed to secure hazardous items in a locked cabinet or didn’t keep them out of reach.

Insurance coverage

Liability coverage under a homeowners or renters policy may help if a guest becomes sick due to negligence in the storage or labeling of toxic substances. However, intentional acts or criminal negligence aren’t covered.

Preventing Poisoning

Around 77% of poisonings are unintentional. For children under 6, the largest group to experience household poisoning, 99% are unintentional.[4]

In these cases, the most common exposures were due to cleaning substances, analgesics or cosmetic products. To make your home safe for your own children and young guests, take the following steps.

  • Store all poisonous or hazardous substances out of the reach of children or in cabinets secured with safety latches.
  • Read all labels and follow directions before using a product. 
  • Don't flush unwanted household medications or pour them down the drain. 
  • Teach children not to touch or eat anything they don't recognize. Never call medicine candy.
  • Never leave medicine out on a counter, even if it is in child-safe packaging. 

 

3. Fires and Burns

Kitchen fires, faulty wiring, unattended candles, or space heaters placed too close to curtains can lead to serious injuries and property damage.

In fact, cooking-related fires account for nearly half of all reported home fires in the U.S. each year, with a quarter of a million people suffering burn injuries.[5]

Who’s at fault?

Responsibility depends on the circumstances. If the homeowner failed to maintain electrical systems or ignored known hazards like a faulty stove, they could be liable. But if a guest caused the fire through their own negligence, they might bear responsibility instead.

Insurance coverage

Homeowners insurance typically covers property damage caused by fire, but when it comes to injuries, liability coverage is key. If you’re found responsible for a guest’s burn injury, your policy may pay their medical bills and any related legal expenses.

Preventing Fires and Burns

There are a number of ways to prevent fires and contact burn injuries in the home:

  • Create a kid-free zone around the stove and oven when you're cooking, turn pot handles inward toward the stove and keep hot liquids out of reach of children.
  • Never leave things on the stove or in the oven unattended. 
  • Ensure proper ventilation, especially with gas appliances.
  • Ensure fireplaces and chimneys are inspected regularly and use barriers to prevent children from getting near open flames. 
  • Avoid overloading electric outlets or using appliances near water.
  • Have all electrical work done by a licensed electrician. 

4. Cuts and Lacerations

Broken glass, exposed nails, sharp tools, or even shattered dishes can cause deep cuts requiring stitches.

Every year, emergency rooms treat over 7 million people for cuts and lacerations, many caused by accidents at home.[6] These injuries are more likely in homes undergoing renovations, with cluttered storage areas or during gatherings where glasses and dishes are in heavy use.

Who's at fault?

If a homeowner leaves dangerous objects lying around in a space where guests are likely to be, they could be considered negligent. For example, leaving a box cutter on the kitchen counter at a child’s height could lead to liability if it causes injury.

Insurance coverage

Medical payments coverage can help cover the cost of stitches or treatment, even if the homeowner isn’t technically at fault. If a lawsuit arises, liability coverage steps in.

Preventing Lacerations

To prevent household injuries from lacerations, it's important to be mindful of potential hazards, especially if young children are around. 

  • Store knives, glassware, scissors and tools in secured cabinets and drawers. 
  • Clean up broken glass immediately and dispose of shards in a puncture-proof container. 
  • Avoid distraction when using sharp objects like knives. 
  • Never catch a falling knife!
  • Use a designated container for disposing of used razor blades and other sharp objects.

5. Drowning

Homes with swimming pools, hot tubs or decorative ponds have an added layer of risk.

Drowning is the leading cause of unintentional injury death for children aged one to four, and even near-drowning incidents can cause life-altering injuries.[7] Slips on wet decks, water inhalation, or sudden submersion can happen quickly, especially when supervision lapses.

Who’s at fault?

Pool owners have a duty of care to secure the area, which may include fencing, locked gates and proper supervision. Failure to do so often results in liability if someone is injured or drowns. Even if a guest enters the pool without permission, the homeowner can sometimes be held responsible under “attractive nuisance” laws.

Insurance coverage

Liability coverage generally applies, but pool owners may need higher coverage limits given the potential severity of water-related injuries. Some insurers require specific safety measures to maintain coverage.

Drowning Prevention

Drowning deaths are on the rise in the United States, and it can happen in a matter of seconds. Here's how you can help prevent a tragedy from happening on your property.

  • Build fences that fully enclose the pool. These show separate the pool from the house and have self-latching gates. 
  • Remove all toys from the pool area when not in use. 
  • Supervise children closely when in or near water (bathtubs, pools, etc.).
  • Avoid swimming (especially alone) under the influence of alcohol, drugs, or medications that might impair your coordination or judgment.
  • Learn CPR.
Sources
  1. Deaths in the home. [NSC]

  2. Slip and fall safety. [NSC]

  3. Poisoning Statistics. [Poison Control]

  4. Poison proof your home. [NY Department of Health]

  5. Burn Incidence and Treatment in the United States. [Ameriburn.org]

  6. Learn about lacerations. [MSC]

  7. Drowning Deaths Rise in the United States. [CDC]