Ask an Agent
Have a question? We're here to help.
Ask an agent for free
Question

How do I handle an accident where the person I hit is claiming more damage than what was actually caused?

I was at a stop light when I tapped the person in front of me. We both pulled over to the side of the road to exchange information. There wasn't much damage to either vehicle except for 2 small scratches on the other car's bumper. Now the guy I hit is trying to claim that his tail light was also broken. What should I do?

Jul 30, 2017 Kent, WA

Answer
Author profile picture

The Zebra

The nation's leading independent insurance comparison site

The Zebra is an independent insurance advisor and quote comparison site with headquarters in Austin, Texas. Utilizing its real-time quote comparison …

If you are filing a claim with your insurance company then the simplest solution is to provide them with pictures of the damage from the accident scene. They will investigate the accident and pay for any damage for which you are liable. Whether or not they cover the damaged tail light will not make any difference in the end result of the claim. If you are paying for the damage out of pocket then it is up to you and the other party to come to an agreement on the amount of the repair. If you took pictures at the scene of the accident then you should be able to prove fairly easily that you did not cause any additional damage. Filing a claim through your insurance company, however, will also completely remove you from having to deal with the other party altogether.
Ask an Agent
Have a question? We're here to help.
Ask an agent for free

Insurance is complicated, but it doesn't have to be.

The Zebra searches all of the top insurance companies, in one place, so you can compare the cost and coverage you need to protect your car, home and other property.

Step 1: Tell us a little about yourself

Choose an insurance product and enter your zip code to get started. No phone number required.

Step 2: Sip your coffee while we find the best quotes

Enter the necessary information and then sit back while we find quotes from 100 top insurance carriers.

Icon Fill Form

Step 3: Compare your quotes

Compare quotes side-by-side to find the right match for you, whether it's home, auto, or more.

Icon Agent

Step 4: Let our agents do the hard work for you

Once you pick your policy, our agents are here to get you over the finish line. Then just relax and enjoy your savings.

Compare insurance rates today!

Location pin icon
No junk mail. No spam calls. Free quotes.

Related Questions

Other people are also asking...

What happens if someone makes a false car insurance claim against me?

Thank you for your question. After any accident, I recommend taking pictures and recording as much information as possible. If fault is difficult to determine, call 311 and file a police report. If you have any of this information currently, it can be helpful. At this point, I recommend contacting …
Sep 25, 2019 Madison, WI

Can I group multiple accidents into one claim?

Unfortunately, you would be filing a collision claim which would be categorized by your insurer as an at-fault accident. This will likely cause your rate to increase. And since you have damage to two different areas of your vehicle that came from separate incidents, your insurance company will requ…
Nov 19, 2017 Sacramento, California

If I paid to have a window replaced on my car, can I submit the receipt to my insurance company for reimbursement?

Since you are in California, glass claims should not impact your rate. You will want to make sure your policy includes comprehensive coverage (which it should since you are leasing the vehicle). If the cost to replace the window is less than your deductible, however, you aren't likely to be co…
May 8, 2017 Santa Monica, CA

Someone gave me the wrong insurance information after a claim

I would first try contacting the insurance company they gave you. It could be they are using a new card they received for their policy renewal that hasn't started yet. If they truly did not have insurance at the time of the accident, they will have to pay for the damages out of pocket. If that…
Jul 31, 2018 Machesney Park, IL