TheZebra.com is a privately owned website that publishes unbiased rates and carrier information for consumer benefit. Learn More

Review: Metromile Looks For the Right Formula for Pay-Per-Mile Insurance

Jump to our full Metromile insurance review, including a breakdown of coverage options and ratings. 

When my husband and I moved from Austin, Texas, to San Francisco, California, our driving habits shifted dramatically. We went from driving every day to rarely pulling the car out of the garage. The kicker is that we were paying for full coverage on a car that mostly sat idle. We needed to find another auto insurance plan. I spotted a billboard advertising Metromile, a pay-per-mile car insurance provider, and started researching usage-based insurance.

The first usage-based insurance programs started roughly a decade ago when mainstream providers began offering discounts based on an individual’s driving habits. Since then, new companies, such as Metromile and Root, adopted the model as the core of their business. (Check out our review of Root and this handy comparison chart.) These newcomers offer insurance policies tailored to individual driver behavior, rather than relying on aggregate driver data. For drivers with low mileage and safe driving habits, usage-based insurance can be a more cost-efficient option than traditional auto insurance policies. Below you'll find our Metromile car insurance review that looks at the coverage options, customer satisfaction, and a general overview of how their system works.

 

What makes Metromile insurance different?

You pay a base rate + pennies on the mile

Metromile applies a usage-based insurance formula based on how many miles you drove the previous month. The company starts with a base rate determined by traditional data such as what kind of car you drive, your age and driving history, and credit score. But Metromile then adds their special sauce: your actual mileage multiplied by a cost-per-mile fee. The result is simple: if you drive less, you pay less.

 


 

For drivers with low mileage and safe driving habits, usage-based insurance can be a more cost-efficient option than a traditional insurance plan.

 


 

Metromile’s pricing is directly linked to mileage driven. Users pay a monthly base rate plus a per-mile rate. Metromile tracks your mileage using a wireless device that plugs into your car's diagnostic port.

Metromile does not monitor a driver’s behavior (aside from miles driven) to calculate his or her rate. So if you’re inclined to hard braking and swift turns, Metromile may be a better option for you than Root, which takes those actions into consideration. Metromile is available in Arizona, California, Illinois, New Jersey, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Virginia, and Washington.

For us, switching from a traditional plan to Metromile cut our monthly fee from $120 to less than $50 for the same coverage. Granted, our rate is based on driving roughly 360 miles each month, which is pretty low.

It’s also worth mentioning that Metromile originally relied on National General Insurance to underwrite its policies and service claims. User reviews were not great, and in 2016 Metromile acquired another insurance carrier to bring everything in-house. Now they handle policies and the claims process internally.

 

Metromile Map

 

 

How to sign up for Metromile

The first step is to request an insurance quote. Rest assured that checking your rate won’t affect your credit score. You’ll be asked to enter personal information, like your address and date of birth. Then you’ll need to enter basic information on the vehicle you want to insure, such as the year, make, model, and ownership status.

Next, you’ll be prompted to estimate your monthly mileage. With pay-per-mile insurance, it’s important to provide an accurate estimate. It may not be worth switching from a traditional plan if you’re clocking a lot of miles in your daily commute. Don’t stress over the occasional road trip — Metromile maxes out daily mileage at 250 miles (or 150 miles for folks in New Jersey, lucky you!). You’re nearly off to the races! Now you’ll need to enter the details for the primary insured and any secondary drivers. Nothing new here.

Similar to a traditional insurance plan, you’ll need to select a level of coverage. If you’re confused or need more information, click on the question mark icons next to each field. The explanations are impressively helpful. You also have the option to select add-ons, such as comprehensive insurance, rental car reimbursement, and roadside assistance.

 

Metromile Laptop 5

Metromile Laptop 6

 

At this point, you can use the Calculate Savings tab to compare your current plan with Metromile’s estimate. It’s a quick way to determine if you’ll actually save money on the company's plan. You’ll also see your estimated base rate and the per-mile rate.

 

Metromile Laptop 7

 

Installing the Metromile Pulse

If you opt to proceed with Metromile, you’ll be prompted to review your plan and enter your payment details. You’ll also be asked for your address so the company can ship you its mileage tracking device, the Metromile Pulse. Your device should arrive within five to seven business days. A nice perk is that you’re not charged for mileage during this period.

Once the package arrives, you’ll find a quick start guide and the Pulse device.

The guide provides a helpful diagram of possible locations for your onboard diagnostics port (OBD-II). Though I just Googled the location for my vehicle’s make and model. You’ve got a 10-day grace period (seven days in California) to install the device; from then on, Metromile requires you to keep it connected with a few short-term exceptions, such as car maintenance. (Careful on this one as you can be charged for up to 250 miles per day for every day it’s disconnected.)

Once I found the OBD-II port, the installation was simple. If you’ve ever plugged in a lamp, you can handle it. A small red light goes on to let you know it’s connected. You’ll have to make a short trip to calibrate the device’s GPS, and then you should be good to go.

 

Metromile Kit

 

As the last step, you may want to download the Metromile app for easy mobile access to your account. The app has some handy features, such as up-to-date billing information, a car locator for those of us who can’t remember where we parked, and a street sweeping notification (a feature that would have saved me from a parking ticket just last week). The Pulse is GPS enabled, but you can opt to disable the storage of location-based data if that sort of thing makes you uncomfortable. Just note that you won’t be able to use app features that rely on location-based data.

Overall, I’d say switching to Metromile was straightforward and painless. You can complete the whole process without ever picking up the phone. I prefer to do most things online, so not having to go through an agent was a relief for me. However, I did have a few questions specific to this review and found their customer service to be quick and responsive. Of course, the true test comes with filing a claim, which I hope I won’t have to do anytime soon.

 

How does the Metromile Pulse work?

Making the most of your car's data

The Pulse is powered by telematics technology, which uses your GPS location to record your daily mileage, decode Check Engine Light readings, and act as a locator device if you forget where you park. You keep it plugged in all the time, but there's no reason to worry about it draining your battery. It doesn't have that kind of power. And if you're concerned about the GPS tracking part, you can disable that in your account settings.

 

Meet AVA, Metromile's smart assistant

Using artificial intelligence to automate your claims

Metromile introduced AVA, a service within its mobile app that uses artificial intelligence to collect details and issue payments when you file a claim. Using data from the Metromile Pulse sensor that's plugged into your dashboard, AVA can determine if the details of the claim are accurate, guide you through submitting photos as proof of damage, and help get your payment as soon as possible. If there's a snag, AVA connects you to Metromile's in-house claims team.

 

Metromile Insurance Review for 2020

100% filled Star icon 100% filled Star icon 100% filled Star icon 100% filled Star icon 0.0% filled Star icon

4.0 Rating from The Zebra

Metromile, a San Francisco-based insurance company, offers usage-based auto insurance policies. The company employs telematics technology to build your car insurance pricing profile based on your driving behavior, reducing the weight given to non-driving factors.


Get a Quote

JD Power: Not Rated

Financial Strength — Average: Metromile is not rated by AM Best at this time. 

NAIC Rating — Below Average: According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), Metromile has a complaint ratio much higher than the national average.

JD Power: Not Rated

Financial Strength — Average: Metromile is not rated by AM Best at this time. 

NAIC Rating — Below Average: According to the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), Metromile has a complaint ratio much higher than the national average.

Get a Quote

 

Metromile car insurance considerations

Overall, motorists who don't drive all that much — and who are alright with their driving habits being tracked — could find Metromile insurance beneficial. It offers many of the standard coverage options available from other auto insurance companies, such as liability (bodily injury and property damage), collision, comprehensive, under/uninsured motorist, and medical payments. They even offer additional coverages such as roadside assistance and rental reimbursement. 

While Metromile auto insurance is an intriguing interruption of the car insurance industry, that doesn't necessarily mean that it will always offer the best rates. When trying to find affordable insurance rates, it can pay off to compare premiums from many different auto insurance companies. The Zebra allows you to get insurance quotes from lots of car insurance companies at once, giving you the chance to find the best car insurance policy for your needs.

The Zebra

The Zebra is the nation's leading independent insurance comparison site. The Zebra compares more than 100 insurance companies and provides agent support and educational resources to ensure drivers are equipped to make the most informed decisions about their home and auto insurance.

blog comments powered by Disqus

About The Zebra

The Zebra is not an insurance company. We’re an independent, unbiased partner for consumers, on a mission to help you compare insurance options apples-to-apples, so you can make a truly informed decision. We’re proud because:

  • We're the first to compare all the major insurance companies side-by-side. The information provided on those insurers here is intended to help inform and educate consumers before they decide where to spend their hard-earned cash.
  • We have no stake in which insurance company you choose — we simply want to offer you unbiased, fast, side-by-side comparisons of your insurance options.
  • The rates you receive — and which companies you see — when comparing quotes via The Zebra's comparison tool are subject to the information you provide, and may not match those displayed on this page.