Best Car Insurance for Good Credit

A good credit score is a great way to save on auto insurance.

Best car insurance for good credit


Having a good established credit score can make life much smoother. It’s easier to get loans, apply for housing, and can even help lower your car insurance rates. Whether you know it or not, your credit score is a big rating factor in determining your car insurance rate. Between those who have bad credit and excellent credit, there’s nearly a 50% premium different which comes out to nearly $1400 a year! Even if you have good credit, finding affordable car insurance is still difficult. Let’s explore how to shop for the best car insurance with a good credit report.


Car insurance for drivers with good credit scores
  1. What are the cheapest insurance companies for good credit?
  2. Why does your credit score matter?
  3. How else can you save with good credit?
  4. Additional resources




What are the cheapest car insurance companies by credit rating?


In order to answer this question, we created a user profile (outlined here) and surveyed some top companies across the US looking at credit scores, ranging from fair to excellent. Here are the results:


Annual Insurance Premium by Credit Score

Company Fair (580-669) Good (670-739) Very Good (740-799) Great (800-850)
Allstate $2,403 $1,984 $1,648 $1,383
Geico $2,212 $1,804 $1,490 $1,246
Farmers $1,774 $1,558 $1,396 $1,265
Liberty Mutual $2,335 $1,886 $1,545 $1,281
Nationwide $1,983 $1,628 $1,349 $1,130
Progressive $2,157 $1,802 $1,520 $1,295
State Farm $2,369 $1,947 $1,614 $1,338
USAA $2,277 $1,885 $1,573 $1,312

There is some variance between the idea of a “good” credit score and who you should consider for car insurance. If your credit score is between 670 and 739, Farmers Insurance is the cheapest company for you. But if you boast a credit score of 740 or greater, Nationwide and GEICO offer cheaper car insurance, based solely on credit score.





Why does credit score impact car insurance?


While your credit report may seem unrelated to car insurance, insurance companies consider bad credit an indicator of risk. Studies show drivers with “bad credit” (300-579) file more claims than do drivers with good credit. When drivers with poor credit do file claims, they result in more expensive claim payouts, costing insurance companies more money.

Like having a bad driving record or being a young driver, poor credit is considered a risk by insurance companies. Any time an insurance company senses additional risk, they raise premiums.





How to save on car insurance with good credit


While generally won't pay as much as someone with bad credit, you’re probably paying more than you’d want for car insurance. Outside of looking at the proposed insurance companies we’ve listed, here are some ways to save on car insurance with a good credit report.


Keep that credit score up

As we’ve demonstrated, your credit standing can influence your premium. By keeping your credit score up, you’ll ensure your financial health with other institutions while keeping your car insurance premiums as low as possible.



Be smart with your coverage

Unless you have a classically cool vehicle, your car is going to depreciate in value. As a result, the auto insurance coverage you once had on your ‘99 Geo might not be necessary today. Here’s a good way to tell whether you're over-insured:


  • Do you have a loan on the vehicle?

If you have a loan on the vehicle or are leasing it, you’re required to maintain physical coverage by your loan or lease agreement.


  • If the vehicle is owned, what’s the value of the vehicle compared to its premium?

You can determine the value of your vehicle by using your vehicle's information coupled with Kelley Blue Book or NADA. Next, speak with an insurance agent at your company and ask how much premium your physical coverage (so, comprehensiveand collision) costs.

If the value of the premium (plus your deductible, as you would have to also pay your deductible in the event of a claim) is greater than the value of the vehicle, you might not need this coverage. This is because you’re paying more to insure the vehicle than it’s actually worth.

If you own your vehicle, but it’s still relatively new or you plan to resell it in the future in order to get another vehicle, you probably want to maintain physical coverage in order to protect your investment.


  • If it’s determined you need to keep physical coverage but you’re still looking to save, consider raising your deductible.

Your premium and deductible are inversely related, meaning if you raise your deductible you lower your premium. Be aware, however, by raising your premium you take on a greater financial responsibility in the event of a claim. Which brings us to our third cost-cutting solution; be smart with your claims.



Be smart with your claims

Be smart with your claims means don’t file a claim if you can help it. “If you can help it” is a short and sweet way to say if the dollar value of premium increase plus your deductible is greater than the out of pocket expense of repairing the vehicle, don’t file a claim.* Here’s how to tell:


  1. Get an estimate for the repair damages at a local repair shop
  2. Use our State of Insurance Report to see how much an at-fault accident would raise your premium for your state. Consider that amount of increase over period of 3 years, as that’s how long your insurance company would charge you.
  3. Compare the value of the premium increase plus your deductible to the out of pocket repairs in step 1. If it’s cheaper to file a claim, file a claim.

We understand the point of insurance is to protect your car baby and keep it looking new. But you need to consider the premium ramifications for filing any at-fault claims. For a lot of claims, it’s in your best financial interest to pay for claims out of pocket rather going through your insurance company.

Bear in mind, however, we are referring to collision claims. Comprehensiveclaims, damage caused by animals, theft, or weather-related events, for example, are unlikely to raise your rate as much or at all. Moreover, not-at-fault accidents, shouldn’t affect your rate.

*Please note: If you’re involved in an at-fault accident with another person and they do not want to settle matters out of pocket, you are probably out of options as you're required to exchange insurer information.



Follow our lead

In order to see which company was the cheapest for “good” credit, we surveyed some top insurance companies. While our profile probably doesn’t fit you, you should still consider our model as one to follow. Only by looking as many companies as possible can you determine if you could be getting a better rate elsewhere. Do that here with us.





Additional Resources


If you’re looking for more information on car insurance discounts and ways to save, see here:

Which companies don’t use your credit history

Get car insurance rates

How to shop for car insurance

Best cheap car insurance for bad credit history

Credit score vs. credit report; what’s the difference?

Does your credit score affect your car insurance rate?

Why credit score based insurance isn’t always a good idea


Compare insurance rates from top companies!




Methodology and data sources


Between September and December 2017, The Zebra conducted comprehensive auto insurance pricing analysis using its proprietary quote engine, comprising data from insurance rating platforms and public rate filings. The Zebra examined nearly 53 million rates to explore trends for specific auto insurance rating factors across all United States zip codes, averaged by state, including Washington, DC.

Analysis used a consistent base profile for the insured driver: a 30-year-old single male driving a 2013 Honda Accord EX with a good driving history and coverage limits of $50,000 bodily injury liability per person/$100,000 bodily injury liability per accident/$50,000 property damage liability per accident with a $500 deductible for comprehensive and collision. For coverage level data, optional coverage (that must be rejected in writing) is included where applicable, including uninsured motorist coverage and personal injury protection.

National property and casualty losses information is from the Insurance Information Institute and the NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information U.S. Billion-Dollar Weather and Climate Disasters report.

For vehicle make and model data, analysis referenced the most popular vehicles in the U.S. by 2016 year-end sales according to Goodcarbadcar.net’s automakers’ data.

Finally, some rate data may vary slightly throughout report based on rounding.


Recent Questions:

Best Car Insurance for Good Credit

What do I put in a quote if I don’t have a credit history

Jun 18, 2018

I’m a young and new driver and don’t have established credit history. What do I put in the credit question ...

Is car insurance a hard or soft credit check?

Apr 29, 2018

Is there any insurance companies that don’t check for your credit when trying to purchase insurance? I am trying to ...

Discounts on car insurance after taking a professional safety course for teens

Apr 27, 2018

Are there any discounts for teen drivers if they take a school sponsored course? My daughters are both learning to ...

Why is my insurance so expensive for a 2007 Jeep Grand Cherokee?

Sep 13, 2017

I am 73 years old and drive less than 1,200 miles per year. I had one minor accident in the ...

Additional Resources:

Best Car Insurance for Good Credit

Can Your Bank Force You to Get Car Insurance?
Can Your Bank Force You to Get Car Insurance?
Aug 03, 2017

Wells Fargo is now finding themselves in hot water over the recent reports that they charged over 570,000 customers for...

Survey: Americans in the Dark about Car Insurance
Survey: Americans in the Dark about Car Insurance
Oct 24, 2017

“What you don’t know can’t hurt you…” … is an entirely false statement in the world of auto insurance. Car...

Does Your Credit Score Affect Your Car Insurance Rate?
Does Your Credit Score Affect Your Car Insurance Rate?
Jul 19, 2017

You know you need good credit to take out a loan, a mortgage, or your friend with expensive taste. But...

Religious Exemptions for Car Insurance: Are They Legal?
Religious Exemptions for Car Insurance: Are They Legal?
Aug 09, 2017

In nearly every conceivable scenario, if you’re driving around in a motor vehicle, there is no reason why you should...

Editorial: A Need for Optionality in Insurance
Editorial: A Need for Optionality in Insurance
Sep 19, 2017

Today The Zebra announced that we closed a record-breaking $40 million Series B funding round, led by Accel Partners. As...

7 Car Rental Mistakes That Could Cost You
7 Car Rental Mistakes That Could Cost You
Apr 11, 2017

Rental cars offer tremendous convenience. Whether you need a vehicle to help you explore a vacation destination or get you...

What Happens if You Crash a Zipcar?
What Happens if You Crash a Zipcar?
Jan 09, 2018

Car sharing services like Zipcar and Car2Go allow city dwellers to forego car ownership without losing all of the perks....

When Can You Let Your Friend Drive Your Car (and When Shouldn’t You)?
When Can You Let Your Friend Drive Your Car (and When Shouldn’t You)?
Jul 26, 2017

It’s not uncommon for your friend to share your clothes, your skillet, or your favorite movie. And for those types...

Car Warranty vs. Insurance: Which You Need and When
Car Warranty vs. Insurance: Which You Need and When
Sep 07, 2017

Anyone who has ever owned a “lemon” (a car that’s a dud) knows how stressful and costly car repairs can...

Car Insurance for First-Time Drivers: 6 Things You Should Know
Car Insurance for First-Time Drivers: 6 Things You Should Know
Apr 03, 2017

A driver’s license is more than just permission to take to the open road. To many, including first-time drivers, it...

How Do Car Insurance Companies Determine Rates?
How Do Car Insurance Companies Determine Rates?
Jun 15, 2017

If you’re one of the 250 million drivers in the United States, you’re required by law to have car insurance....

What is the State of Auto Insurance in 2018?
What is the State of Auto Insurance in 2018?
Feb 06, 2018

Well, we’ve done it again. We’ve gone and gotten super curious about how car insurance is impacting the 250 million...

Introducing the Insurability Score: Your Insurance Risk Decoder
Introducing the Insurability Score: Your Insurance Risk Decoder
Oct 24, 2017

Today, The Zebra debuted the Insurability Score™, a personalized calculation which reveals to drivers what is affecting their insurance risk,...

6 Things to Know Before You Get Car Insurance
6 Things to Know Before You Get Car Insurance
Oct 04, 2017

Let’s get one thing out there. No one is especially psyched to get car insurance. You get it because it’s...

5 Tips to Consider Before Financing Your Car
5 Tips to Consider Before Financing Your Car
Apr 21, 2017

Buying a new (or new-to-you) car can be an overwhelming process. First, you need to research all your options to...

Digital Insurance Cards: Which States Accept Them?
Digital Insurance Cards: Which States Accept Them?
May 19, 2017

You probably already take care of your banking errands on your phone (thanks, mobile check deposits!). You may have shown...

Does Your Car Insurance Policy Cover Flooding?
Does Your Car Insurance Policy Cover Flooding?
Aug 07, 2017

If you don’t live in a flood plain, making sure your car insurance covers flood damage might be low on...

How to File a Car Insurance Claim: Steps, Timing, and Costs to Expect
How to File a Car Insurance Claim: Steps, Timing, and Costs to Expect
Dec 01, 2017

You get in an accident or your car is pummeled with hail. You need to figure out how to get...

CLUE Report: Why Does it Matter for Your Home and Auto Insurance?
CLUE Report: Why Does it Matter for Your Home and Auto Insurance?
Jun 06, 2017

When searching for an insurance policy, it’s important for consumers to do their due diligence and compare quotes before choosing...

Car Insurance for Seniors
Car Insurance for Seniors
May 26, 2017

Some senior stats for you: By 2030, one in five Americans will be over 65. The first of the baby...

Do Keyless Ignitions Actually Put Your Car – and Your Life – at Higher Risk?
Do Keyless Ignitions Actually Put Your Car – and Your Life – at Higher Risk?
Dec 14, 2017

No broken windows. No lengthy process of wedging the door open. No hotwiring, no alarm, no concerned passerby dialing 911....

6 Reasons to Leave Your Car Insurance Company
6 Reasons to Leave Your Car Insurance Company
May 05, 2017

You might be familiar with a few scenarios that could make your auto insurance rates change: You bought a new...

How to Update Your Driver’s License When You Move to a New State
How to Update Your Driver’s License When You Move to a New State
Jul 28, 2017

Moving to a new state can be an exciting adventure. As with most moves, it requires a bit of paperwork...

What I Learned After Totaling My Car 450 Miles from Home
What I Learned After Totaling My Car 450 Miles from Home
Jan 03, 2018

This past May, I took a road trip from Rhode Island to West Virginia to attend a friend’s wedding. Despite...

What Are Your Options When Your Car Lease Ends?
What Are Your Options When Your Car Lease Ends?
Jul 17, 2017

Of course there are many reasons you might want to lease your car. Perhaps you like the idea of driving...