Ford Mustang Car Insurance

Compare all car insurance companies at once.

The Ford Mustang is a costly car to cover, with mean annual outlays $524 in excess of the national mean. The Mustang provides bad cost-to-insure value, with a costlier-than-average insurance rate-to-MSRP ratio.

Plymouth Rock Insurance offers the cheapest auto insurance rates for the Ford Mustang, with an average annual rate of $814 — 48% more affordable than the average of popular insurance companies. The priciest car insurance carrier for the Ford Mustang is Liberty Mutual, offering an average premium of $4,453 annually.

Analyze the pricing information below to shop Ford Mustang auto insurance premiums from popular car insurance companies.

How much does it cost to insure my Ford Mustang?

Select the year of your car

2017 Ford Mustang

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$814

Texas Farm Bureau

$1,097

Quincy Mutual

$1,163

Progressive

$1,227

USAA

$1,276

State Farm

$1,419

GEICO

$1,594

Allstate

$2,034

Arbella

$2,171

Amica

$2,911

MetLife

$3,130

Liberty Mutual

$4,453

Compare all 2017 Ford Mustang insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,703

List Price

$25,185

Trims Available

V6, EcoBoost, EcoBoost Premium, GT, GT Premium, Shelby GT350, Shelby GT350R

2015 Ford Mustang

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$775

Texas Farm Bureau

$930

Quincy Mutual

$1,107

Progressive

$1,177

USAA

$1,280

State Farm

$1,370

Arbella

$1,382

Amica

$1,388

GEICO

$1,429

Allstate

$1,804

MetLife

$1,892

Liberty Mutual

$2,502

Compare all 2015 Ford Mustang insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,329

List Price

$23,800

Trims Available

V6, EcoBoost, EcoBoost Premium, GT, GT Premium, GT 50 Years Limited Edition

2014 Ford Mustang

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$753

Texas Farm Bureau

$828

GEICO

$865

Quincy Mutual

$1,079

Arbella

$1,118

Amica

$1,131

Progressive

$1,142

USAA

$1,208

State Farm

$1,316

Allstate

$1,397

MetLife

$1,540

Liberty Mutual

$2,012

Compare all 2014 Ford Mustang insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,174

List Price

$22,510

Trims Available

V6, V6 Premium, GT, GT Premium

2013 Ford Mustang

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$748

Texas Farm Bureau

$812

Quincy Mutual

$1,051

Amica

$1,095

GEICO

$1,099

Arbella

$1,139

USAA

$1,140

Progressive

$1,145

State Farm

$1,316

Allstate

$1,509

MetLife

$1,563

Liberty Mutual

$2,025

Compare all 2013 Ford Mustang insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,171

List Price

$22,200

Trims Available

V6, V6 Premium, GT, GT Premium, Boss 302

2012 Ford Mustang

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$723

Texas Farm Bureau

$792

GEICO

$973

Quincy Mutual

$1,027

Amica

$1,096

USAA

$1,098

Arbella

$1,102

Progressive

$1,121

State Farm

$1,212

MetLife

$1,497

Allstate

$1,548

Liberty Mutual

$1,935

Compare all 2012 Ford Mustang insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,123

List Price

$22,310

Trims Available

V6, V6 Premium, GT, GT Premium, Boss 302

2011 Ford Mustang

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$677

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$683

Texas Farm Bureau

$768

Quincy Mutual

$1,002

Amica

$1,016

Progressive

$1,028

Arbella

$1,031

USAA

$1,051

State Farm

$1,119

Allstate

$1,299

MetLife

$1,436

Liberty Mutual

$1,820

Compare all 2011 Ford Mustang insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,046

List Price

$22,145

Trims Available

V6, V6 Premium, GT, GT Premium