Tesla Model S Car Insurance
Compare all car insurance companies at once.
The Tesla Model S is an affordable vehicle to cover via auto insurance, with average annual rates $388 more affordable than the national average. The Model S offers good cost-to-insure value, with a below-average insurance rate-to-MSRP quotient.
Progressive provides the most affordable auto insurance prices for the Tesla Model S, with a mean annual premium of $539 — 68% less than the average of top insurance companies. The most expensive car insurance provider for the Tesla Model S is Infinity, with a mean cost of $4,279 per annum.
Dive into the data below to see Tesla Model S insurance rates offered by top auto insurance companies.
How much does it cost to insure my Tesla Model S?
Select the year of your car
2017 Tesla Model S
Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost
Progressive
$539
GEICO
$545
$554
USAA
$585
$637
Erie
$648
$727
$772
$784
$786
Texas Farm Bureau
$849
Allmerica
$886
Compare all 2017 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$791List Price
$68,000Trims Available
60, 60D, 75, 75D, 90D, P100D
2016 Tesla Model S
Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost
Progressive
$393
State Farm
$517
GEICO
$532
USAA
$568
Erie
$619
Country
$626
Nationwide
$729
Cincinnati Insurance
$729
American Family
$747
Plymouth Rock Insurance
$749
Texas Farm Bureau
$785
Allied
$791
Compare all 2016 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$733List Price
$66,000Trims Available
60, 70, 60D, 75, 70D, 75D, 90D, P90D
2015 Tesla Model S
Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost
Progressive
$392
State Farm
$504
GEICO
$538
USAA
$565
Erie
$601
Country
$634
Plymouth Rock Insurance
$670
Cincinnati Insurance
$722
American Family
$728
Nationwide
$741
Texas Farm Bureau
$767
Tennessee Farmers
$775
Compare all 2015 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$721List Price
$69,900Trims Available
60, 70D, 85, 85D, 90D, P85D, P90D
2014 Tesla Model S
Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost
Progressive
$377
State Farm
$518
GEICO
$548
USAA
$555
Erie
$584
Country
$623
Plymouth Rock Insurance
$723
American Family
$725
Cincinnati Insurance
$746
Nationwide
$760
Texas Farm Bureau
$803
Allied
$825
Compare all 2014 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$777List Price
$69,900Trims Available
60, 85, Base, P85, Performance, P85D
2013 Tesla Model S
Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost
Plymouth Rock Insurance
$692
Progressive
$733
State Farm
$759
Erie
$779
USAA
$882
GEICO
$922
$939
Country
$1,034
$1,051
Nationwide
$1,087
Cincinnati Insurance
$1,140
Texas Farm Bureau
$1,316
Compare all 2013 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$1,294List Price
$59,900Trims Available
Base, Performance
2012 Tesla Model S
Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost
State Farm
$442
Progressive
$676
Plymouth Rock Insurance
$684
Erie
$781
USAA
$789
Mercury
$939
GEICO
$952
Nationwide
$960
Quincy Mutual
$1,027
Country
$1,070
Cincinnati Insurance
$1,182
Texas Farm Bureau
$1,280
Compare all 2012 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$1,153List Price
$57,400Trims Available
Base, Performance, Signature, Signature Performance