Tesla Model S Car Insurance

Compare all car insurance companies at once.

Your information is secure.

The Tesla Model S is an affordable vehicle to cover via auto insurance, with average annual rates $388 more affordable than the national average. The Model S offers good cost-to-insure value, with a below-average insurance rate-to-MSRP quotient.

Progressive provides the most affordable auto insurance prices for the Tesla Model S, with a mean annual premium of $539 — 68% less than the average of top insurance companies. The most expensive car insurance provider for the Tesla Model S is Infinity, with a mean cost of $4,279 per annum.

Dive into the data below to see Tesla Model S insurance rates offered by top auto insurance companies.

How much does it cost to insure my Tesla Model S?

Select the year of your car

Model S Car Insurance

2017 Tesla Model S

Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost

Progressive

$539

GEICO

$545

$554

USAA

$585

$637

Erie

$648

$727

$772

$784

$786

Texas Farm Bureau

$849

Allmerica

$886

Compare all 2017 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$791
List Price
$68,000
Trims Available

60, 60D, 75, 75D, 90D, P100D

2016 Tesla Model S

Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost

Progressive

$393

State Farm

$517

GEICO

$532

USAA

$568

Erie

$619

Country

$626

Nationwide

$729

Cincinnati Insurance

$729

American Family

$747

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$749

Texas Farm Bureau

$785

Allied

$791

Compare all 2016 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$733
List Price
$66,000
Trims Available

60, 70, 60D, 75, 70D, 75D, 90D, P90D

2015 Tesla Model S

Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost

Progressive

$392

State Farm

$504

GEICO

$538

USAA

$565

Erie

$601

Country

$634

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$670

Cincinnati Insurance

$722

American Family

$728

Nationwide

$741

Texas Farm Bureau

$767

Tennessee Farmers

$775

Compare all 2015 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$721
List Price
$69,900
Trims Available

60, 70D, 85, 85D, 90D, P85D, P90D

2014 Tesla Model S

Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost

Progressive

$377

State Farm

$518

GEICO

$548

USAA

$555

Erie

$584

Country

$623

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$723

American Family

$725

Cincinnati Insurance

$746

Nationwide

$760

Texas Farm Bureau

$803

Allied

$825

Compare all 2014 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$777
List Price
$69,900
Trims Available

60, 85, Base, P85, Performance, P85D

2013 Tesla Model S

Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$692

Progressive

$733

State Farm

$759

Erie

$779

USAA

$882

GEICO

$922

$939

Country

$1,034

$1,051

Nationwide

$1,087

Cincinnati Insurance

$1,140

Texas Farm Bureau

$1,316

Compare all 2013 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$1,294
List Price
$59,900
Trims Available

Base, Performance

2012 Tesla Model S

Cheapest Insurance Companies
Average Annual Cost

State Farm

$442

Progressive

$676

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$684

Erie

$781

USAA

$789

Mercury

$939

GEICO

$952

Nationwide

$960

Quincy Mutual

$1,027

Country

$1,070

Cincinnati Insurance

$1,182

Texas Farm Bureau

$1,280

Compare all 2012 Tesla Model S insurance rates.
Average Cost to Insure Per Year
$1,153
List Price
$57,400
Trims Available

Base, Performance, Signature, Signature Performance