Toyota Corolla Car Insurance

Compare all car insurance companies at once.

The Toyota Corolla is an average-cost vehicle to cover, with average annual outlays $16 greater than the nationwide mean. The Corolla provides poor cost-to-insure value, thanks to its above-average insurance rate-to-MSRP ratio.

Plymouth Rock Insurance offers the most affordable car insurance premiums for the Toyota Corolla, with an average yearly premium of $709 — 59% less than the average among top insurance companies. The priciest car insurance carrier for the Toyota Corolla is Liberty Mutual, with an average premium of $2,219 per annum.

Dive into the information below to find Toyota Corolla auto insurance rates from top car insurance providers.

How much does it cost to insure my Toyota Corolla?

Select the year of your car

2018 Toyota Corolla

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$704

USAA

$714

Erie

$736

Progressive

$862

State Farm

$901

Tennessee Farmers

$964

Nationwide

$1,072

American Family

$1,177

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,193

Vermont Mutual

$1,226

Allied

$1,296

Acuity

$1,307

Compare all 2018 Toyota Corolla insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,092

List Price

$18,600

Trims Available

L, LE, LE Eco, SE, XLE, XSE

2017 Toyota Corolla

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$653

Erie

$708

USAA

$747

State Farm

$851

Progressive

$858

Tennessee Farmers

$964

Texas Farm Bureau

$964

Nationwide

$1,092

American Family

$1,155

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,163

Quincy Mutual

$1,163

Vermont Mutual

$1,175

Compare all 2017 Toyota Corolla insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,061

List Price

$18,500

Trims Available

L, LE, LE Eco, SE, XLE, 50th Anniversary Special Edition, XSE

2016 Toyota Corolla

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$570

Erie

$617

USAA

$641

State Farm

$720

Progressive

$785

Texas Farm Bureau

$860

Tennessee Farmers

$861

American Family

$984

Nationwide

$1,031

Vermont Mutual

$1,037

Country

$1,089

Quincy Mutual

$1,131

Compare all 2016 Toyota Corolla insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$915

List Price

$17,300

Trims Available

L, LE, LE Eco, LE Plus, S, LE Eco Plus, S Plus, S Special Edition, LE Premium, LE Eco Premium, S Premium

2015 Toyota Corolla

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$572

Erie

$597

USAA

$639

State Farm

$702

Progressive

$773

Texas Farm Bureau

$862

Tennessee Farmers

$957

American Family

$984

Vermont Mutual

$1,009

Nationwide

$1,053

Country

$1,092

Quincy Mutual

$1,107

Compare all 2015 Toyota Corolla insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$901

List Price

$16,950

Trims Available

L, LE, LE Eco, LE Plus, S, LE Eco Plus, S Plus, LE Premium, LE Eco Premium, S Premium

2014 Toyota Corolla

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$550

Erie

$612

USAA

$634

State Farm

$711

Progressive

$799

Texas Farm Bureau

$810

Vermont Mutual

$942

Tennessee Farmers

$948

American Family

$991

Acuity

$1,071

Quincy Mutual

$1,079

Nationwide

$1,081

Compare all 2014 Toyota Corolla insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$900

List Price

$16,800

Trims Available

L, LE, LE Eco, LE Plus, S, LE Eco Plus, LE Premium, S Plus, LE Eco Premium, S Premium

2013 Toyota Corolla

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$522

Erie

$625

USAA

$660

Texas Farm Bureau

$779

State Farm

$788

Progressive

$813

Vermont Mutual

$892

Tennessee Farmers

$940

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,029

American Family

$1,037

Quincy Mutual

$1,051

Acuity

$1,069

Compare all 2013 Toyota Corolla insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$925

List Price

$16,230

Trims Available

L, LE, S, LE Special Edition, S Special Edition

2012 Toyota Corolla

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$499

Erie

$597

USAA

$622

State Farm

$673

Progressive

$738

Texas Farm Bureau

$771

Vermont Mutual

$846

Tennessee Farmers

$914

American Family

$974

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,005

Acuity

$1,018

Quincy Mutual

$1,027

Compare all 2012 Toyota Corolla insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$872

List Price

$16,130

Trims Available

L, LE, S

2011 Toyota Corolla

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$472

Erie

$550

USAA

$564

State Farm

$628

Progressive

$715

Texas Farm Bureau

$736

Vermont Mutual

$791

Tennessee Farmers

$870

American Family

$894

Arbella

$973

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$985

Quincy Mutual

$1,002

Compare all 2011 Toyota Corolla insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$829

List Price

$15,900

Trims Available

Base, LE, S