Toyota Highlander Car Insurance

Compare all car insurance companies at once.

The Toyota Highlander is a moderately affordable car to cover via car insurance, with average annual outlays $100 more affordable than the national mean. The Highlander supplies poor cost-to-insure value, with a more expensive-than-average insurance rate-to-MSRP quotient.

Plymouth Rock Insurance offers the cheapest car insurance rates for the Toyota Highlander, with a mean yearly rate of $733 — 68% cheaper than the average among top insurance companies. The most expensive car insurance carrier for the Toyota Highlander is Liberty Mutual, offering an average price of $1,773 annually.

Dive into the pricing information below to review Toyota Highlander car insurance rates offered by established auto insurance companies.

How much does it cost to insure my Toyota Highlander?

Select the year of your car

2018 Toyota Highlander

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$760

Erie

$778

Progressive

$901

USAA

$919

Tennessee Farmers

$969

Nationwide

$1,013

Vermont Mutual

$1,032

Allied

$1,077

Acuity

$1,114

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,155

Country

$1,160

Arbella

$1,208

Compare all 2018 Toyota Highlander insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,199

List Price

$31,230

Trims Available

LE, LE Plus, XLE, SE, Limited, Limited Platinum

2017 Toyota Highlander

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$735

Erie

$753

Texas Farm Bureau

$809

Progressive

$883

Tennessee Farmers

$961

Vermont Mutual

$979

Nationwide

$996

USAA

$1,001

Acuity

$1,091

Allied

$1,098

State Farm

$1,102

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,123

Compare all 2017 Toyota Highlander insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,075

List Price

$30,630

Trims Available

LE, LE Plus, XLE, SE, Limited, Limited Platinum

2016 Toyota Highlander

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$625

Erie

$680

Texas Farm Bureau

$783

Progressive

$796

USAA

$880

Tennessee Farmers

$917

Vermont Mutual

$924

Nationwide

$999

Acuity

$1,047

State Farm

$1,060

Country

$1,066

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,092

Compare all 2016 Toyota Highlander insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,000

List Price

$30,490

Trims Available

LE, LE Plus, XLE, Limited, Limited Platinum

2015 Toyota Highlander

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

Erie

$700

Texas Farm Bureau

$768

GEICO

$773

Vermont Mutual

$898

Progressive

$902

USAA

$909

Tennessee Farmers

$930

Acuity

$1,027

Country

$1,078

State Farm

$1,082

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,084

Nationwide

$1,085

Compare all 2015 Toyota Highlander insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$1,021

List Price

$29,765

Trims Available

LE, LE Plus, XLE, Limited, Limited Platinum

2014 Toyota Highlander

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$638

Erie

$662

Texas Farm Bureau

$744

USAA

$824

Progressive

$833

Vermont Mutual

$841

Tennessee Farmers

$898

Acuity

$958

State Farm

$983

Country

$1,026

Nationwide

$1,032

Plymouth Rock Insurance

$1,051

Compare all 2014 Toyota Highlander insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$956

List Price

$29,245

Trims Available

LE, LE Plus, XLE, Limited, Limited Platinum

2013 Toyota Highlander

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$533

Erie

$640

Texas Farm Bureau

$706

USAA

$740

Vermont Mutual

$741

Progressive

$784

Tennessee Farmers

$813

Acuity

$893

Nationwide

$926

State Farm

$929

Arbella

$955

Country

$956

Compare all 2013 Toyota Highlander insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$891

List Price

$29,020

Trims Available

Base, Plus, SE, Limited

2012 Toyota Highlander

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$515

Erie

$625

Texas Farm Bureau

$696

Vermont Mutual

$700

USAA

$737

Progressive

$770

Tennessee Farmers

$794

State Farm

$838

Acuity

$847

Nationwide

$891

Country

$924

Arbella

$937

Compare all 2012 Toyota Highlander insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$860

List Price

$28,240

Trims Available

Base, SE, Limited

2011 Toyota Highlander

Cheapest Insurance Companies

Average Annual Cost

GEICO

$547

Erie

$629

Vermont Mutual

$684

Texas Farm Bureau

$694

USAA

$740

Progressive

$787

Tennessee Farmers

$800

Arbella

$825

State Farm

$898

Country

$907

Nationwide

$909

American Family

$945

Compare all 2011 Toyota Highlander insurance rates.

Average Cost to Insure Per Year

$868

List Price

$28,090

Trims Available

Base, SE, Limited