Car Insurance after a PIP Claim

How to handle auto insurance following a Personal Injury Protection claim.

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.

Which car insurance companies are cheapest after a PIP claim?

On average, one Personal Injury Protection (PIP) claim will raise your car insurance premium $4 per year. Let’s explore the ins and outs of car insurance with a PIP claim, including what Personal Injury Protection covers, which companies offer the most affordable PIP coverage, and some helpful tips on how to use this insurance.

  1. What is a PIP claim?
  2. Cheapest insurance providers after a PIP claim
  3. Additional resources


What is a PIP claim?

A PIP claim occurs when you use Personal Injury Protection to cover damages caused as a result of a car crash. This coverage, which is required in 12 no-fault states, is designed to cover the below expenses for you and your passengers:

  • Medical care and treatment
  • Lost wages
  • Ambulance fees
  • Medication costs
  • Death benefits

This coverage does not apply to any property damage or bodily injury inflicted upon drivers outside of your vehicle. Moreover, the coverage applies no matter which driver is deemed at-fault.


How much PIP coverage should you have?

The amount of PIP coverage needed is often determined by your state. Michiganfor example, requires unlimited PIP. As a result, Michigan drivers face expensive car insurance costs. Other states, like Floridarequire PIP to cover 80% of medical bills and 60% of lost wages, up to $10,000.



What are the cheapest insurance companies after a PIP claim?

The amount you will pay after a PIP claim will vary considerably depending on your company and the circumstances of the claim. We generated a national average rate after a PIP claim by using a sample driving profileUSAA is the cheapest insurance provider after one PIP claim, followed by GEICO and State Farm.

Car Insurance CompanyAverage 6-month premium
State Farm$664


If you do not qualify for USAA, GEICO will be your next cheapest option at $657 for a six-month policy.


Find affordable auto insurance today!

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.


Additional resources

Your experience after a PIP claim may vary considerably from our example. Because of the high cost of claims payouts, many companies drop clients should they accumulate more than three PIP claims in a three-year period. If you’re currently in a situation where you cannot find insurance because of your driving record, your best option is to shop with non-standard insurance companies.

These smaller companies sometimes provide coverage to a higher-risk pool of clients. If you’re interested in speaking to an agent to find coverage after a PIP claim, call 888-444-2833 or click below!


Need coverage after a PIP claim?


Should you file a PIP claim or use your health insurance?

If you are injured in a car accident, your health insurance will usually require you use your PIP coverage as your primary and potentially use your health insurance as the secondary. However, some states have exemptions to this rule. In New Jerseyfor example, you can use your health insurance as your primary form of medical care if you elect to.


Med Pay vs. PIP:

Medical payments coverage, or Med Pay, provides fewer coverage options than PIP. While they both provide medical and funeral benefits, Med Pay provides no coverage for loss of wages or living expenses.


Related content


Compare over 200 insurance companies at once!

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.