Homeowners Insurance After a Cancellation or Non-Renewal

Being dropped by your insurance company can be frustrating. Learn how to find a new policy and potentially save money.

Location pin icon
glyph-shield-checkmarkNo junk mail. No spam calls. Free quotes.

Homeowners insurance after cancellation or non-renewal

Receiving a notice of cancellation or non-renewal from your insurance company can be an unpleasant surprise. Home insurance cancellation can be frustrating, as finding a new policy after being dropped can sometimes be a challenge.

Because homeowners insurance is typically required by your mortgage lender, it’s imperative to find a new insurance policy in order to protect your investment and satisfy your lender’s requirements. Read on to discover why insurance companies drop policyholders, as well as how to get a home insurance policy after you’ve been dropped. 


Cancellation and non-renewal: table of contents
  1. Home insurance cancellation vs. non-renewal
  2. Common reasons for home insurance non-renewal
  3. How to get a new policy after cancellation
  4. Frequently asked questions
  5. How to save money after a home insurance cancellation



Home insurance cancellation vs. non-renewal

An insurance cancellation and a non-renewal each signify a break between you and your insurer, but they occur for different reasons. Technically, a homeowners insurance company can cancel your policy for any reason within 60 days of the policy's inception. Once your policy has been active for more than 60 days, a cancellation usually only happens in one of two circumstances:

  • Non-payment of premiums
  • Breach of policy terms

Missing payments puts you at risk of being dropped by your carrier. Similarly, any instance of fraud can be grounds for cancellation. This may include lying about a claim or misrepresenting information on your application.

Non-renewals usually occur near the end of a policy period. If an insurer decides not to renew your policy, you will be notified beforehand. Legal notification requirements vary by state, but insurers are usually required to give customers between 30 and 60 days notice in the event of non-renewal.

Bear in mind a non-renewal can come from the homeowner. If you shop around and find better coverage at a cheaper rate, moving on from your current home insurance company to another is considered a non-renewal.



Common reasons for home insurance non-renewal

There are a number of reasons an insurance provider might elect to drop a policyholder. Non-renewal may occur as a result of a policyholder’s profile, though it can also stem from a higher-level change at an insurance company. Below are some of the primary reasons for insurance non-renewal:


Non-renewal due to filing too many insurance claims 

Those with extensive claims history are considered high-risk by most insurance companies. Not only are high-risk homeowners more likely to be dropped by their carriers, but they also face higher insurance premiums on average when they find a new insurer. Learn more about how to get insurance as a high-risk homeowner.


Non-renewal due to changes in the company’s coverage options or area(s) of coverage

In some cases, an insurer may find that certain coverages are not financially viable. This means that — at the minimum — you would essentially have a new policy after your current one ends. In some cases you could be non-renewed, forcing you to look elsewhere for coverage.

Homeowners in California have struggled with such changes in recent years as many home insurance companies have attempted to void and refuse coverage in areas prone to wildfires or other natural disasters


Non-renewal because your insurance profile no longer meets the company's requirements 

Your personal profile has an impact on whether or not an insurance company wants to provide coverage. Essentially, if the risk that you represent is too great to make financial sense, your insurer is not likely to renew your policy.

This could include situations as varied as the following:

  • You own a dog breed considered dangerous
  • A home inspection finds unacceptable risks (age of the roof, HVAC system, etc.)
  • Changes or renovations made to your home or property violate the policy’s terms
  • Adding a business to your home



How to get a new policy after being dropped

Home insurance cancellation can be frustrating and worrying. Finding a new policy that doesn’t drown you in higher premiums can be difficult. Chances are your search could be difficult because of the same reasons you were dropped.

However, going without coverage is inadvisable for many reasons, not least that gaps in your coverage will negatively affect your rates or ability to find affordable coverage.

The best option that most homeowners have is to shop around. While having a high number of home insurance claims is likely to make your rates higher, it’s very likely that another company will be able to offer you an affordable policy. 

If you are struggling to find affordable homeowners insurance, you might consider whether or not your state offers any relief. Many states have what is known as a FAIR plan, which can help to alleviate the financial burden of those who may not otherwise be able to afford a home insurance policy. The Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) Plan is a government-run program that can help homeowners find basic coverage. These policies do not provide as much coverage as a private plan but are an option of last resort that helps homeowners find coverage and adhere to the requirements of their lending company.



Frequently asked questions about home insurance non-renewal

Can homeowners insurance companies drop you in the middle of your policy term?

In short, yes, but only in certain situations. Insurance companies can usually drop you for any reason during the first 60 days of your policy. However, to be dropped in the middle of a policy period, policyholders will have had to have missed payments or committed fraud that violates the policy terms

The most common way for an insurance provider to drop insurance coverage is through non-renewal. This will happen at the end of your current policy period. You will receive a notice of cancellation informing you of the decision, giving you enough time to secure another home insurance policy. 

Policyholders facing non-renewal or cancellation must be given between 30 or 60 days' notice (depending on your state) from an insurance company if it is planning on canceling your coverage.


Can a policyholder fight insurance cancellation?

There are steps that you can take. If you feel that your home policy is being unjustly canceled, your first course of action is to call your insurer. If that does not yield the results you are looking for, you could consider filing a complaint with your state’s department of insurance. Keep in mind, however, that a non-renewal may come about for reasons unrelated to you. This can include changes in their coverage offerings or the company simply writing fewer policies in certain areas. 


How can homeowners prevent homeowners insurance from being canceled?

To avoid homeowners policy cancellation, keep your home well-maintained and pay insurance premiums on time (at a minimum). Think twice about filing claims when the damages can be fixed out-of-pocket, as too many claims can make you seem like a risk to an insurer. It can also be a good idea to have your insurance company do an inspection before writing your policy. These actions — along with abiding by your insurance provider’s guidelines — can keep you from being surprised by a cancellation notice or non-renewal. 



Ways to save money after a homeowners insurance cancellation

In order to satisfy the requirements of your mortgage company, you will have to find homeowners coverage. Those who have had their policies canceled may find getting cheap coverage to be difficult, but there are ways to save money. 

For instance, look for discounts by finding an insurance provider who can offer both home and auto insurance under the same roof. Likewise, carrying a higher deductible can also save money on monthly payments while simultaneously discouraging you from filing unnecessary claims, thereby reducing your chance of being dropped by your insurer. 

Overall, the best way to save on homeowners insurance is to shop around. The Zebra can help you find insurance quotes from the nation’s top insurance companies, allowing you to compare rates and policy details.

For those who have unique homeowners insurance needs, The Zebra’s in-house insurance agents can help answer questions and find a policy that is a good fit for your needs.

Simply enter your ZIP code or give us a call at 1-888-255-4364 to get started.

Compare homeowners insurance companies side-by-side!

Location pin icon
glyph-shield-checkmarkNo junk mail. No spam calls. Free quotes.
Ross Martin LinkedIn

As a licensed insurance agent, Ross is responsible for researching and writing about all matters related to auto and home insurance. He has a background in writing and education, as well as a master's degree from Royal Holloway, University of London. He has been quoted by CNET, iDriveSafely.com, and Kin Insurance.