Why you can trust The Zebra

The Zebra partners with some of the companies we write about. However, our content is written and reviewed by an independent team of editors and licensed agents. Reference our data methodology and learn more about how we make money.

Author profile picture

Renata Balasco

Content Strategist

Credentials
  • Licensed Insurance Agent — Property and Casualty

Renata joined The Zebra in 2020 as a Customer Experience Agent. Since 2021, she has worked as licensed insurance professional and content strategist.…

Author profile picture

Nathan Foster

Agency Trainer

Credentials
  • Licensed Insurance Agent - Property and Casualty

Nathan is an insurance professional with a focus on creating positive customer experiences with more than 10 years of industry experience.

Nathan tra…

Author profile picture

Kristine Lee

Manager, Content and Data

Credentials
  • Licensed Insurance Agent — Property and Casualty

Kristine is a licensed insurance agent who joined The Zebra in 2019 as an in-house content researcher and writer. Before joining The Zebra, she was a…

How much does car insurance cost in New York City?

The cost of auto insurance in New York is around $2,273 for a six-month policy or $379 per month on average. As per our 2023 data, National Grange Mutual is the most affordable car insurance company in New York, offering rates as low as $849 for a six-month policy. But remember, while National Grange Mutual's insurance might be less expensive, it may not offer the best coverage for your needs. Keep reading to learn about other reasonably priced alternatives for auto insurance in New York.

In New York state, car insurance costs an approximate total of $1,011 every six months. These rates are also higher than the national average of $742 every six months. It's worth mentioning that around 35% of New York customers believe that they are paying too much for their auto coverage. If you're one of these customers or if you're simply curious about the car insurance options available to you, read on to learn more about New York rates and the factors that impact them.

Car Insurance in New York City vs. New York Avg. 6 Mo. Premium
New York City Average $2,273
New York Average $1,011
Updated: 09/28/23.

The cheapest car insurance companies in New York City

1st place medal
1st place: National Grange Mutual

National Grange Mutual, the flagship company of Main Street America Insurance, offers the lowest rates in New York City for full coverage insurance. A six-month policy costs an average of $849, or $142 per month. 

2nd place medal
2nd place: Progressive

Progressive takes second place with average rates at $1,310 for a six-month policy.

3rd place medal
3rd place: GEICO

Finally, our third-cheapest carrier in New York City is GEICO. GEICO premiums start at $1,372 for six months. 

The Zebra's key takeaways about car insurance in New York City:

  • The average cost of a car insurance policy in New York City is $2,273 per six-month policy — $379 per month.
  • The cheapest company in New York City is National Grange Mutual ($849).
  • New York City ranks as the 19th most expensive city for car insurance in New York.
  • 35% of Zebra customers in New York City stated they used our product because they were paying too much for car insurance with their current provider.

Are you paying too much for auto insurance?

Location pin icon
No junk mail. No spam calls. Free quotes.

New York City car insurance rates by company

Our records for 2023 indicate that National Grange Memorial is the most affordable company for full-coverage auto insurance in New York, with rates starting at $142 per month or $849 per six-month policy. Progressive comes in second with a monthly cost of $218 or a total of $1,310 for six months. Both businesses provide a variety of insurance choices to fulfill your automobile insurance needs, but keep in mind that each company may have different qualifications or pricing disparities based on your profile.

For more information on the highest-rated car insurance companies, refer to The Zebra's Customer Satisfaction Survey.

 

Cheapest car insurance companies in New York City, NY
Company Avg. 6 Mo. Premium
National Grange Mutual $849
Progressive $1,310
GEICO $1,372
Travelers $1,603
USAA $1,832
State Farm $2,014
Allstate $2,064
Updated: 09/28/23.

Dynamic auto insurance data methodology

Methodology: The auto insurance rates displayed above and throughout this page are dynamic, meaning the data will refresh when the most recent information is made available. Rates are based on a sample driver profile — a 30-year-old single male driver with a Honda Accord and full coverage. This profile was adjusted based on common pricing factors used by major car insurance companies, like age, coverage level, driving record and others.


Shop around for the best rates


The most effective way to find affordable car insurance that meets your needs is to shop around and compare rates. With our convenient comparison tools, we'll take care of the difficult work, so you can focus on choosing the best coverage. Enter your ZIP code to view rates from Progressive, State Farm, Allstate, and other top companies to find the ideal and most inexpensive car insurance in New York.

Location pin icon
No junk mail. No spam calls. Free quotes.

Average car insurance in New York City by rating factor

Finding a car insurance company that covers everything you need without being too expensive can be a real pain. All companies use similar rating factors, but they all do it differently. Some might put a lot of weight on your credit score, while others care more about how many times you've made a claim.

To make sure you're always getting the best prices, you need to get new quotes every six months or so.

Q: I didn't have an accident — Why is my insurance going up?

A: End-of-year earnings play a significant role in determining the cost of car insurance in New York, as they consider the revenue generated by premiums compared to the cost of claims paid out to policyholders. Even if you have never made a claim and have an impeccable driving history, you may still face higher rates from some insurance providers due to the increased expenses associated with conducting business in the city.

Auto insurance premiums by age in New York City

Age is among the many factors used when computing insurance rates. Insurance providers use statistics to determine the likelihood of drivers being involved in accidents or making claims. Unfortunately, teenagers have the highest accident rate compared to any other age group. Consequently, they are charged the highest premiums. In New York, the discrepancy between the rates paid by teenage drivers and those in their 20s can be as high as 140%.

Insurance companies aim to manage risk, and insuring a teenage driver can appear disproportionately expensive or unreasonable. Teenagers present a higher risk of accidents, and to balance the increased cost of claims, insurers charge them higher premiums.

 

Cheapest car insurance companies for teen drivers in New York City, NY
Company Avg. 6 Mo. Premium
National Grange Mutual $2,156
Progressive $3,479
Travelers $4,051
GEICO $4,732
State Farm $7,006
USAA $7,203
Allstate $11,403
Updated: 09/28/23.
Age Bracket Cheapest Companies Avg. 6 Mo. Premium
20s National Grange Mutual $1,105
30s National Grange Mutual $784
40s National Grange Mutual $754
50s National Grange Mutual $766
60s National Grange Mutual $826
70s National Grange Mutual $1,134

Zebra Tip: The cheapest companies for New York City drivers between 30-40 are National Grange Mutual, GEICO, and Progressive


Based on our data, the age range of 30-39 encompasses the majority of New York drivers. This group typically pays $2,310 every six months. By selecting these providers, savings of 49% are possible.

Auto insurance premiums for minimum coverage in New York City

The insurance rates you pay are closely linked to the level of coverage you select. Based on our research, 31% of New York drivers have the minimum required state coverage. Although drivers are only required to have a certain level of coverage, if you opt for the bare minimum, you run the risk of being underinsured in case of a claim.

You will be charged more for your policy if you add collision coverage or comprehensive coverage, also known as "full coverage" when purchased jointly. However, the additional peace of mind that comes with these coverages can be invaluable. These coverages typically require a deductible, which can vary in amount and will also impact your rate. If you opt for a higher deductible, your rates will be more affordable. On the other hand, if you prefer a lower deductible, you'll have to pay more for your policy.

As New York is a no-fault state, minimum coverage also requires that drivers carry uninsured motorist coverage and personal injury protection (PIP). In addition to that, you should take into account features such as roadside assistance. Including this option in your policy will raise your insurance premium, but The Zebra suggests them since it adds an extra level of protection for you later on.

Q: Can I lower my car insurance coverage?

A: Possibly — if your vehicle is paid off.

Our data analysis revealed that 51% of drivers in New York have owned vehicles. In case you're not leasing or financing your car, you might want to consider whether dropping comprehensive or collision coverage is the best decision for you. We advise that you obtain the actual cash value of your vehicle from a reputable source like Kelley Blue Book. Generally, if your car is valued at less than $4,000, you probably won't need collision coverage. Just remember that if you opt out of these coverages, you'll have to pay for any repair expenses if you're in an accident.

Cheapest car insurance companies for minimum coverage in New York City, NY
Company Avg. 6 Mo. Premium
National Grange Mutual $459
GEICO $678
Progressive $813
USAA $814
Travelers $991
Allstate $1,159
State Farm $1,263
Updated: 09/28/23.
  • Minimum: State liability coverage only
  • Basic: State liability + collision and comprehensive (full) coverage
  • Better: Better liability limits at 50/100/50. Full coverage included with towing and rental car benefits. May include additional personal medical benefits and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.
  • Best: Best liability limits at 100/300/50. Full coverage included with better towing and rental car benefits and better personal medical benefits and increased uninsured/underinsured coverage.

Most of our customers in New York opt for the basic level of coverage, but this may not be the best option for everyone. While we understand state minimum coverage is a budget-friendly solution, it does leave you at risk for damages that exceed your liability limits. New York's 25/50/10 liability limits provide coverage for damage you cause up to $25,000 per person in bodily injury, $50,000 per accident in bodily injury and $15,000 for property damage. While this may be sufficient for most standard car accidents, it might not be for bodily injury claims or multi-vehicle accidents. New York is a no-fault state, so drivers must also carry uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage and personal injury protection (PIP)

Learn more about insurance laws in New York.

New York City car insurance rates by credit score

For most states, such as New York, determining insurance premiums involves considering credit score. When insurers calculate rates, credit score is just as important as age and driving history. But why is this the case? Analysis of historical data reveals that drivers with lower credit scores tend to file more claims, have coverage gaps, and engage in riskier driving behaviors. Thus, insurance companies perceive individuals with higher credit scores as less risky, leading to reduced rates. Enhancing your credit score can be a practical way to obtain affordable auto insurance.

New York drivers whose credit scores range from 300-579 pay 208% more than those with scores of 800-850, according to our analysis. The data shows that most New York drivers have a credit score categorized as "good (680-719)." In 2023, National Grange Mutual and Progressive are the cheapest insurance options for New York drivers in the credit tier.

Cheapest car insurance companies for bad credit in New York City, NY
Company Avg. 6 Mo. Premium
GEICO $1,673
Travelers $3,164
USAA $3,542
Allstate $4,071
State Farm $4,389
National Grange Mutual $4,884
Progressive $10,988
Updated: 09/28/23.

Zebra Tip: If you recently improved your credit score, shop around for car insurance!


In New York, car insurance rates are heavily influenced by credit scores. Drivers with "Poor" credit pay 94% more per year for car insurance than those with "Fair" credit, according to our data. If you've taken steps to improve your credit, you might be able to save money on car insurance. Consider checking your credit monitoring service to see if your recent efforts have paid off.

Auto insurance rates with an at-fault accident

The most frequently filed insurance claims pertain to accidents categorized as at-fault and collisions. After an at-fault accident in 2023, the average monthly car insurance rates in New York increased from $379 to $511, marking a 35% rise. The New York-based insurance company that provides the most affordable rates following an at-fault accident is National Grange Mutual, with Progressive coming in as a close second for savings.

To keep your auto insurance rates affordable, it is crucial to avoid accidents and citations and maintain a clean driving record, regardless of where you live. Reckless driving charges, speeding citations, at-fault accidents, and DUIs and DWIs all lead to rate increases. While the duration of the impact on your premium is generally three to five years, DUIs and DWIs can have a more lasting impact on your rates.

 

Cheapest car insurance companies after an at-fault accident in New York City, NY
Company Avg. 6 Mo. Premium
National Grange Mutual $1,126
Progressive $1,760
Travelers $1,945
GEICO $1,958
USAA $2,304
State Farm $2,773
Allstate $2,900
Updated: 09/28/23.

New York City car insurance rates by violation

Below you can see how much different violations and claims will increase your rate in New York City.

Car insurance rate increases after violations and citations in New York City, NY
Accident/Violation Avg. 6 Mo. Premium % Rate Increase $ Rate Increase
None $2,273 0% $0
One Med/PIP claim $2,273 0% $0
One comp claim $2,295 1% $22
Two Med/PIP claims $2,307 2% $35
Not-at-fault accident $2,319 2% $46
Two comp claims $2,324 2% $51
Failure to show documents $2,339 3% $66
Failure to wear a seat belt $2,345 3% $72
Child safety restraint $2,366 4% $93
Driving without lights $2,366 4% $93
Driving with expired registration $2,374 4% $101
Cell phone violation $2,402 6% $129
Texting while driving $2,402 6% $129
Failure to yield $2,402 6% $129
Wrong way/wrong lane $2,402 6% $129
Following too closely $2,402 6% $129
Failure to stop at a red light $2,402 6% $129
Illegal turn $2,402 6% $130
Improper passing $2,402 6% $130
At-fault accident - less than $1000 $2,403 6% $131
Passing school bus $2,409 6% $136
Driving too slowly $2,441 7% $168
At-fault accident - $1000-$2000 $2,441 7% $169
Speeding in school zone $2,458 8% $185
Speeding 6 - 10 MPH over limit $2,502 10% $230
Speeding 11 - 15 MPH over limit $2,503 10% $230
Operating a vehicle without permission $2,589 14% $316
Open container $2,640 16% $367
In 65 MPH zone $2,660 17% $387
Speeding 16 - 20 MPH over limit $2,734 20% $461
Speeding 21 - 25 MPH over limit $2,823 24% $550
At-fault accident - greater than $2000 $3,067 35% $794
Reckless driving $3,267 44% $995
Racing $3,292 45% $1,019
Driving with a suspended license $3,487 53% $1,214
Leaving scene of an accident/hit and run $3,646 60% $1,373
Refusal to submit to a chemical test $3,700 63% $1,428
DUI $3,718 64% $1,445
Updated: 09/28/23.

Why is car insurance in New York City so expensive?

When it comes to auto insurance, New York residents may find themselves paying more than they'd like. This is due to a variety of factors, one of which is the higher cost of living in New York than in other cities, leading insurers to charge more to compensate for this. Your driving history, credit score, and coverage level are all critical factors that impact your rates, but they're not the only ones.

In this piece, we'll explore the reasons why auto insurance in New York can be expensive, even if you're a responsible driver.

weather
Storm risk

Due to where the island of Manhattan is situated, it is at a naturally higher risk for damage incurred from storms and high winds. In fact, the Insurance Information Institute reported that New York, NY ranked the number one metropolitan area at risk for storm surge and hurricane wind[1]. Damage to vehicles and other property caused by storms can cost insurance companies thousands in claim payouts, making this a premiere reason why car insurance in Manhattan is so expensive. 

If it's within your budget, consider adding comprehensive coverage to your policy. This coverage applies when damage occurs to your car for reasons other than collision— handy in places with high probabilities of weather events. 

no fault image
New York is a no-fault state

Drivers who live in no-fault states tend to pay more in car insurance premiums due to the state-required insurance laws. In addition to bodily injury and property damage, drivers in no-fault states like New York must also carry uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage and personal injury protection. These additional required coverages add to overall premiums significantly. 

criminal icon
Crime statistics

As one of the busiest and most popular cities in America, New York City experiences its fair share of crime. In Manhattan, there is a higher risk of theft and vandalism to vehicles, causing insurance companies to compensate with higher-than-average premiums. 

uninsured
Uninsured drivers

As with many large cities, New York City has a higher population than more remote areas in the state, which means that there are more cars on the road. More cars lead to more accidents in general. The costs of accident-related claims are generally passed along to other drivers in the area through higher premiums — this applies even to safe or infrequent drivers.

Based on our data, only 62% of drivers in New York City are insured, leaving the rest without protection. If you happen to have an accident with an uninsured driver in New York City, you may have to pay for the entire repair cost yourself.

Zebra tip: Consider uninsured property damage coverage


If you live in New York City areas with high percentages of uninsured drivers, it's a good idea to carry uninsured motorist coverage (UMPD). This coverage can help if you or your vehicle is damaged by an uninsured or underinsured driver. UMPD coverage typically has a lower deductible and is less expensive than collision coverage. Additionally, the rate increase following a UMPD claim can be significantly less expensive than after a collision claim.


Bundling insurance policies in New York City

Car insurance premiums always seem to be rising, no matter where you live, but there are still ways to save money on your auto coverage. One easy way to save when shopping for a new policy is by bundling your homeowners or renters insurance with your car insurance. By bundling, you may be able to save up to 10% on combined premiums. Discover how combining home and auto insurance can help you save money, no matter where you live.

Don't miss out on potential savings by keeping your car and home insurance policies separate. Spend some time comparing rates from various insurers and see which one offers the best bundling discount.

 

bundling home and auto insurance in nyc
Cheapest car insurance companies for bundling home and auto insurance in New York City, NY
Company Avg. 6 Mo. Premium
National Grange Mutual $739
Progressive $1,232
GEICO $1,235
Travelers $1,443
State Farm $1,679
USAA $1,832
Allstate $1,857
Updated: 09/28/23.

Your insurance rates are not something that you can manage, but the most effective approach to finding economical auto insurance is to compare quotes from a variety of companies. It can be stressful to find a rate that balances coverage with your budget. Remember to consider personal factors that may have an impact on your rate, such as moving, aging, or enhancing your credit score.

It is important to note that some companies are more expensive than others, so don't hesitate to explore all of your options.

Find the best rates for both auto and home insurance in minutes!

Location pin icon
No junk mail. No spam calls. Free quotes.

Frequently asked questions

According to our data, the average car insurance policy for full coverage insurance in New York City is $379 each month, or $2,273 every six months. The cheapest insurance company in NYC is National Grange Mutual with policies starting at $142 per month.

Car insurance in New York City is some of the most expensive in the country, outpacing the national average by more than 200% and remains 36% higher than the New York state average.

New York drivers are required to hold the state minimum liability limits on their car insurance (25/50/10) plus uninsured motorist coverage and personal injury projection.


Find affordable rates in minutes!

Location pin icon
No junk mail. No spam calls. Free quotes.

How much is car insurance near me? — explore more cities near New York, NY


Recently answered questions about car insurance in New York City from real Zebra customers

Car insurance near me in New York City

Other people are also asking...

What are my options if I am paying over $700 a month in car insurance?

Unfortunately, it would appear that your girlfriend's insurance company sees her as a high-risk driver. This would explain her coverage being dropped and the new policy having expensive rates. There are many factors that come into play when insurance companies determine rates. Your driving rec…
Jun 5, 2019 New York City, NY

Who pays for hit and run damage if there's no UMPD coverage in NY?

Uninsured Motorist Property Damage (UMPD) is not a coverage that is offered in New York. If your policy has collision coverage, you can now use that to repair any damages from a hit-and-run. Or if the situation calls for it, you can also take legal action against the at-fault party. For more inform…
Jan 20, 2019 New York City, NY

How do I sell my car to an out-of-state buyer?

You will need to transfer the title of the vehicle to the new buyer. It is important that you fill in all of the appropriate areas required in the title certificate when selling the vehicle to another party. Once the buyer has the title in their name then they will need to title and register the ve…
Jul 29, 2017 New York City, NY

About The Zebra

The Zebra is not an insurance company. We publish data-backed, expert-reviewed resources to help consumers make more informed insurance decisions.

  • The Zebra’s insurance content is written and reviewed for accuracy by licensed insurance agents.
  • The Zebra’s insurance content is not subject to review or alteration by insurance companies or partners.
  • The Zebra’s editorial team operates independently of the company’s partnerships and commercialization interests, publishing unbiased information for consumer benefit.
  • The auto insurance rates published on The Zebra’s pages are based on a comprehensive analysis of car insurance pricing data, evaluating more than 83 million insurance rates from across the United States.