The Zebra doesn't support your browser version, so please give us a call or upgrade your browser to the latest version.
Which company ranks #1 in customer satisfaction and holds the best financial strength rating?
There many ways to measure the best insurance provider. You could compare insurers' customer service, their coverage options, claims satisfaction, or simply contrast their prices. Determining which is the best auto insurance company for you comes down to what you're looking for.
We assessed each and every car insurance provider in the US, analyzing their financial strength, J.D. Power Ratings, and customer satisfaction levels. Compare companies below or click here to see the best car insurance companies of 2019 in aggregate.
Our top car insurance company of 2019 is UPC Insurance, a Florida-based company that writes home and car insurance policies in 12 states along the southern coast. UPC specializes in coverage for hurricane-prone areas. If you live along the coast, you understand the difficulty of finding quality auto insurance, let alone coverage from a company with a "superior" financial strength rating and a stellar J.D. Power rating.
You might be more familiar with our other leading insurance companies. Nationwide, Progressive, State Farm, and Farmers are among the U.S.' most popular auto insurers — for good reason, based on the below findings.
|Rank||Customer Service||Claims Satisfaction (J.D. Power)||Financial Strength (A.M. Best)||The Zebra Rating|
|6. 21st Century||A+||3/5||Excellent||3/5|
|11. First National||A+||3/5||Excellent||4/5|
|15. State Farm||A++||3/5||Superior||3.5/5|
Customer service is important. If you need help understanding your coverage or require support during the claims process, you might consider customer satisfaction ratings as a good place to start your search for the car insurance company with the best customer service.
|Car Insurance Provider||Customer Service Rating|
|2. State Farm||A++|
|4. 21st Century||A+|
|10. American Freedom||A+|
Car insurance is designed to cover your assets in the event of a crash or incident. You should look for an insurance company with enough financial fortitude to protect and replace your insured assets in the event of a lawsuit or loss. Below are top auto insurance companies in order of their financial strength levels.
|Car Insurance Provider||Financial Strength|
|10. Baldwin & Lyons||Superior|
|11. Cincinnati Insurance||Superior|
|15. Tennessee Farm Bureau||Superior|
J.D. Power ratings can tell you a lot about a product or company. The company creates reports based on consumer feedback, detailing a variety of industries. See below the top-rated insurance companies in the US by J.D. Power's recent ratings.
|Car Insurance Provider||J.D. Power Rating|
|4. New Jersey Manufacturers||5|
|7. American Family||4|
|8. The Hartford||4|
If you're looking for more info on car insurance, see our additional and related articles.