What is a Comprehensive Car Insurance Claim?

How does a comprehensive claim impact auto insurance rates?

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.

What is a comprehensive claim for auto insurance?

Comprehensive insurance is an optional addition available with most car insurance policies. It covers damage caused by or related to theft, animals, vandalism, and weather. You should think of it as coverage that doesn’t cover your vehicle's colliding with something (that would be handled via collision coverage). On average, a comprehensive claim will raise your premium by $31 every six months.

  1. Examples of comprehensive car insurance claims
  2. Cheap car insurance with a comprehensive claim
  3. Additional resources


What is comprehensive car insurance? Examples of claims:

Comprehensive coverage insures against damage that does not occur as a result of colliding with another car. Below are some common examples of when comprehensive coverage could be used to cover a claim:

What does comprehensive auto insurance cover?

  • Flood damage and weather-related occurrences
  • Damage caused by animals (insects, rodents, etc.)
  • Collision with a deer or other animal
  • Stolen car or vandalism

Costs associated with routine wear and tear are not covered by comprehensive auto insurance. Insurance strictly restricts coverage on maintenance costs.

Comprehensive vs. collision: what's covered?

Collision and comprehensive coverage work together to protect against physical damage to your vehicle. In an accident, your collision coverage insures your vehicle when it collides with another object. Examples of this include:

  • A collision with another vehicle or vehicles
  • A crash into a fixed object, such as a pole or a wall

Learn more about the differences between collision and comprehensive auto insurance.



Finding cheap car insurance after a comprehensive claim

Using a methodology outlined here, we found a comprehensive claim raises auto insurance rates by $31 over the course of a standard six-month policy, on average. NationwideState Farm, and GEICO offer the cheapest car insurance policies after a comprehensive claim.

6-month premium w/ no claim
6-month premium w/ comprehensive claim
Allstate - $945
Farmers - $797
GEICO - $657
Liberty - $797
Nationwide - $654
Progressive - $788
State Farm - $655


While Nationwide provides the cheapest rate based on our research, your circumstances could differ. What you pay for car insurance will ultimately depend on you and your driving history. Enter your ZIP code below to compare personalized quotes!

Find affordable car insurance today!

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.


Comprehensive vs. collision claims: which cost more?

Comprehensive claims tend to cost much less than collision or liability insurance claims. Insurance providers tend to see comprehensive claims as occurring outside the control of the driver. On average, a collision claim will raise your premium $303 for a standard six-month policy.

Another important note to keep in mind is the accident surcharge most insurance companies will assess. After a ticket or claim, you can be rated, i.e., charged for three to five years. For example, a comprehensive claim with Nationwide increases six-month premiums by $21. If Nationwide continues to price the policy at this rate for at three years, the $21 surcharge adds up to $126 extra.



How to save after a comprehensive claim

Depending on the insurance company and situation, a comprehensive claim can be expensive. Here are some cost-cutting solutions to consider:

Don’t pay for coverage you don't need

Depending on the value of your vehicle, you might not need comprehensive or collision coverage.If your car is worth less than $4,000, it's typically recommended to drop these coverages. These coverages, while required if have a leased or financed vehicle, are not legally required in any state in the US.

You can determine the value of your vehicle with the help of Kelley Blue Book or NADA Online. If you do need these coverages but still want to save, consider raising your deductible. Deductibles and premiums have an inverse relationship: a higher deductible will lower how much you pay for car insurance each month.

Consider a usage-based insurance policy

Usage-based insurance programs use in-car and/or mobile telematics devices to monitor the way you drive and to determine your premium. With telematics-based insurance, the more safely you drive, the less you will pay for auto insurance. Below are estimated savings from major auto insurance providers.


Estimated Savings

Progressive SnapShot

Average of $130

Allstate Drivewise

Average of 10-25%

State Farm Drive Safe & Save

Up to 15%

Esurance DriveSense


Nationwide SmartRide

Up to 40%

Liberty Mutual RightTrack

Average of 5-30%


Aside from the aforementioned companies, consider additional providers such as Root and Metromile.Root derives auto insurance premiums from clients' driving habits, while Metromile offers pay-as-you-go, mileage-based auto insurance.

Double-check for discounts

Most discounts will not drastically reduce your premium. However, they can help you save. Consider the below discounts when shopping for a new policy.

Use your coverage sparingly

Although we’ve outlined that comprehensive claims are not that expensive, having multiple claims can put you at risk to be dropped by your insurance provider. While it can vary, three claims within a three-year period may result in policy non-renewal or cancellation.

This rule can apply to roadside assistance and windshield claims as well as your liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage.

If you’re unsure of whether to file a claim after a car accident, take the following steps:

  1. Get an estimate of the damages
  2. Use ourState of Insuranceanalysis to see how much an accident (comprehensive or collision) would raise your rates in your state. Remember: this cost could continue for three years.
  3. If the cost of the out-of-pocket repair costs is less than the rate increase plus your deductible, pay for it yourself.

For more information regarding whether or not to file a claim, see our guide.

Related content

If you’re looking for additional information on the claims process — or car insurance in general — see our related content:


Compare insurance companies today!

Location pin icon
Your information is secure.

Recent Questions:

What is a Comprehensive Car Insurance Claim?

My car was keyed 4 months ago. Is it too late to file a claim with my insurance company?

The statute of limitations on property damage and injury claims in Ohio is two years — so you are well within the time frame to file a claim. The car being keyed would count as an act of vandalism, so your comprehensive coverage should cover the damage.

I cut down a big tree and it fell on my truck. Will insurance cover that?

Your insurance should cover the damages minus your deductible. In this case, you would file a comprehensive claim for the damage.

Someone attempted to steal my neighbor's vehicle and wrecked my van, how do I handle insurance?

You would not be at fault in this case. In cases like this, it's best to get all the documentation you can, like a police report. If you have comprehensive and collision, you should be able to get your car fixed.

Will my rates go up if I file a claim for a vandalized windshield?

A comprehensive claim can affect your insurance rating. However, most carriers are alright with allowing one such claim per three year period.